Discrimination Suit Against FLDS Dominated Town Can Continue

Cooke v. Town of Colorado City, Arizona, 2011 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 52356 (D AZ, May 16, 2011), is one of the first cases reflecting the implications of a Utah federal district court's holding in February-- now stayed pending appeal-- invalidating the Utah state court's appointment of a special fiduciary to reform the polygamous FLDS Church's United Effort Plan Trust. The UEP trust holds property in Utah and Arizona on which church members reside. (See prior posting.)  The special fiduciary, as part of his efforts to assign property of the trust to beneficiaries in a religiously neutral manner, granted a lease to a parcel of land to Ronald Cooke, a former FLDS member, and his wife. Cooke left the church at age 18 or 19 and moved to Phoenix where subsequently he was severely injured in an accident.  After receiving the lease for land in Colorado City, Cooke and his wife moved back in a trailer home, but the city refused to provide water, electricity and sewer service.  Cooke in this case sued for damages under the federal and state fair housing acts and under 42 USC 1983, alleging that Colorado City engaged in religious and disability discrimination. Meanwhile, after the Utah federal court invalidated the state court's appointment of the special fiduciary, Robert Black, the prior occupant of the Colorado City land leased to the Cooke's, filed an action in Arizona federal district court seeking a declaration that he is the rightful occupant. The court in this decision refused to stay proceedings in Cooke's lawsuit. The city had sought a stay pending the outcome of Black's declaratory action.