Wednesday, June 22, 2011

Australian Judge Acquits Woman Who Could Not Be Identified Because She Wore Burqa

A new debate over women wearing the burqa has broken out in Australia after a district court judge on Monday reversed a magistrate's conviction of a woman for filing a false police report.  Carnita Matthew was charged after a police video proved false a claim that police tried to tear her burqa off her face when she was stopped for  a random traffic breath test and then cited for improper display of her license plates. The judge reversed the conviction because the woman who filed the police report was wearing a burqa at the time and the court concluded that it could not be proved beyond a reasonable doubt that the woman was Ms. Matthew. He was also unconvinced that the woman filing the report knew it was false.  Australia's Telegraph, reporting on the case, says that Matthew has a long history of traffic tickets and non-payment of traffic fines. The government is considering a new requirement that anyone giving a report to police furnish a fingerprint along with their signature.  The government is waiting for the judge's full written opinion before deciding whether to appeal.