Denial of Permit For Church To Lease Space To School Is Upheld

In Calvary Christian Center. v. City of Fredericksburg, 2011 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 77489 (ED VA, July 18, 2011), a Virginia federal district court refused to grant a preliminary injunction to a church that was denied a special use permit that it sought in order to lease space in the church to a for-profit school for disabled children. The court rejected claims under the American for Disabilities Act, the Rehabilitation Act and RLUIPA. In rejecting the RLUIPA claim, the court concluded that the church was unlikely to be able to prove that leasing space for operation of a private school on church property amounts to an exercise of religion, nor that denial of the special use permit would amount to a substantial burden on religious practice. The church had argued that operation of the school was tied to its social ministry.