North Carolina Supreme Court Upholds Campus Police Power On Religiously Affiliated Campus

In State v. Yencer, (NC Sup. Ct., Nov. 10, 2011), the North Carolina Supreme Court upheld North Carolina's Campus Police Act against an Establishment Clause challenge. At issue was the power of the campus police at Davidson College, a Presbyterian Church-affiliated liberal arts college. The state court of appeals, relying on earlier state Supreme Court precedent, had held it unconstitutional for the state to delegate police powers to a religious institution. (See prior posting.) However the Supreme Court disagreed, concluding that the earlier cases  relied upon by the court of appeals pre-dated the enactment of the Campus Police Act which added provisions to ensure neutral, uniform enforcement of the law by campus police.  The Supreme Court held:

this is not a case in which a statute delegates unbridled discretionary governmental powers to a religious organization. The delegation of limited power to campus police officers here “does not result in an 'excessive' entanglement that advances or inhibits religion.

The Burlington Times-News reports on the decision.