In
Owasso Kids for Christ v. Owasso Public Schools,
2012 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 23000 (ND OK, Feb. 23, 2012), Owassso Kids for Christ (OKFC), a Christian group that wants to share its religious message with students and parents, sued complaining that they were not give the same access as other community organizations for distributing flyers and posting information in the Owasso, Oklahoma public schools. The court held first that an individual plaintiff in the lawsuit, one of the founders of OKFC, has standing to bring a civil rights claim on behalf of OKFC which is an unincorporated association. Moving to the merits of plaintiffs' claim for a preliminary injunction, the court held that the fact the school system has issued a new viewpoint-neutral policy on access to the flyer distribution program, bulletin board, open house events, and for the posting of signs on School property does not automatically dispose of plaintiffs' free speech claim. There is at least a question of whether the new policy is in fact being applied in a viewpoint-neutral manner.
The court went on to hold that an evidentiary hearing will be required if the parties do not reach a settlement:
The evidence submitted by the parties is insufficient for the Court to determine whether the public address system, bulletin board, open house events, and the posting of signs on school property constitute designated public fora or nonpublic fora.... [Plaintiff] has also not shown ... that she was denied access to the speech fora because of the religious nature of her speech. The Court reserves factual findings on these issues, because the record is insufficient for the Court to determine [Plaintiff's] likelihood of success on the merits as to these speech fora.
