Tuesday, March 20, 2012

Certiorari Denied In Clergy Abuse and College Student Organization Cases

The U.S, Supreme Court yesterday denied certiorari in two unrelated cases. It denied review in Doe v. Roman Catholic Archdiocese of St. Louis, (Docket No. 11-840, cert. den. 3/19/2012) (Order List). In the case, a Missouri appellate court rejected plaintiff's claim against the Archdiocese of St. Louis for intentional failure to supervise one of its priests who sexually abused plaintiff as a teenager.  The court held that under Missouri law, a duty to supervise arises only as to activity that takes place on Church premises or that occurs while the priest was using a chattle belonging to the church. It also followed Missouri precedent holding that the 1st Amendment bars assertion of tort claims against a religious institution based on its alleged negligence in supervising, retaining, or hiring sexually abusive clerics. (See prior posting.) Bloomberg News reports on the Supreme Court's denial of review.

The Supreme Court also denied review in Alpha Delta Chi- Delta Chapter v. Reed, (Docket No. 11-744, cert. den. 3/19/2012) (Order List). In the case, the 9th Circuit upheld the facial constitutionality of a San Diego State University policy that denies recognition to any student group that restricts membership or eligibility to hold officer positions on the basis, among others, of religion. However, the 9th Circuit concluded that plaintiffs had raised a triable issue of fact as to whether the University applied the policy in a discriminatory manner in denying recognition to a Christian fraternity and sorority, while granting recognition to certain other groups that limit their membership. (See prior posting.) The San Francisco Chronicle reports on the Supreme Court's denial of certiorari.