Turkish Military Court Applies European Human Rights Precedents To Conscientious Objectors

A Turkish millitary court last week handed down an important decision on the rights of conscientious objectors.  Both Hurriyet Daily News and BIA News Agency report on the March 7 decision by the Malatya Military Court in the case of Muhammed Serdar Delice. While the court refused to recognize Delice as a conscientious objector-- finding that he deserted because of financial and psychological problems-- the court for the first time held that protections of the European Convention on Human Rights should be applied in conscientious objector cases. Pointing to the provisions of Art. 90 of the Turkish Constitution that provide that international agreements duly put into effect have the force of law, the Turkish court referred to last year's decision by the European Court of Human rights in Bayatyan v. Armenia holding that that Art. 9 of the European Convention on Human Rights protects military conscientious objectors. (See prior posting.)