Ohio High Court To Review Science Teacher's Firing

As reported by the Columbus Dispatch, the Ohio Supreme Court last week agreed to hear an appeal in Freshwater v. Mount Vernon City School District Board of Education. (Links to court filings and grant of review.) In the case, a state appeals court upheld the firing of John Freshwater, a middle school school science teacher. The school board based the firing on Freshwater's injecting his religious views, including belief in Creationism, into the classroom and for insubordination in failing to remove certain religious materials from the classroom after being ordered to do so by the school board. (See prior related posting.) The Court granted review on two issues: (1) whether Freshwater could be fired if the school board has not provided a clear indication of the kinds of materials or teaching methods that are unacceptable; and (2) whether the mere presence of religious texts from the school's library and/or the display of a patriotic poster can justify his firing. [Thanks to Don Byrd for the lead.]