Friday, September 07, 2012

South Dakota High Court Dismisses Claims Based On Sex Abuse At Indian Reservation School

As reported by the Sioux City Journal, the South Dakota Supreme Court on Wednesday, in two opinions, dismissed several claims that had been filed by a number of former students of St. Paul's School on the Yankton Indian Reservation.  Plaintiffs claimed they had been sexually abused over 35 years ago while attending the boarding school that was operated by various Catholic religious orders and organizations.  In Bernie v. Blue Cloud Abbey, (SD Sup. Ct., Sept. 5, 2012), the court held that the extended statute of limitations for childhood sexual abuse in effect when the suit was filed does not extend the time for filing suit against the religious orders or the Diocese of Sioux Falls, as opposed to the claims against the perpetrators themselves. The extended limitation period only applies to suits alleging intentional conduct involving an act that would have constituted a felony. It does not apply to claims against "non-perpetrating defendants who are sued for negligence or on other theories of liability not involving intentional, criminal conduct."

In Bernie v. Catholic Diocese of Sioux Falls, (SD Sup. Ct., Sept. 5, 2012), the South Dakota Supreme Court rejected a respondeat superior claim against the Diocese of Sioux Falls because the alleged acts "were solely in the perpetrators’ own interests and were not in furtherance of the pursuit of any Diocesan business."  It also rejected negligence and breach of fiduciary duty claims against the Diocese because plaintiffs failed to show an agency relationship between the Diocese and the religious orders operating the school. Nor did the Diocese's relationship with the students create a fiduciary duty of protection.