California Trial Court Issues Tentative Ruling Against Episcopal Church In Property Dispute

A California state trial court has issued a tentative ruling (full text), subject to change if either party requests oral argument, in Diocese of San Joaquin v. Schofield, (Fresno Super. Ct., March 6, 2013). The case involves an attempt by The Episcopal Church to establish its title to property of the break-away San Joaquin Diocese.  As previously reported, a state appeals court held that the trial court should apply neutral principles of law to determine the validity of property transfers allegedly made by break-away Bishop John-David Schofield before he was replaced. The Episcopal Church moved for summary judgment, arguing that because all the property transfers occurred after Schofield was removed as Bishop, the transfers were invalid. The court, in its tentative ruling, however refused to grant the motion, saying:

It is not enough for plaintiffs to merely state that Schofield was not the Episcopal Bishop of the Diocese of San Joaquin when he effected the transfers at issue. Plaintiffs were also required to show that, under neutral principals of law, Schofield lacked the authority to effect such transfers.... An individual incorporated as a corporation sole "may at any time amend the articles of incorporation of the corporation...."   (Corp. Code, § 10010.)... Plaintiffs have utterly failed to present either facts or evidence from which this court could conclude that the December 8, 2007 amendments enacted to leave the Episcopal Church were invalid.... In short, there is nothing to for this court to review under neutral principals of law.

Anglican Curmudgeon blog comments on the tentative ruling.