No 1st Amendment Bar To Suit Against Diocese Over Priest Sex Abuse

In Givens v. St. Adalbert Church, 2013 Conn. Super. LEXIS 1704 (CT Super. Ct., July 25, 2013), a Connecticut trial court rejected the contention of a Catholic diocese that the 1st Amendment and the ministerial exception doctrine preclude civil courts from deciding claims against religious institutions growing out of sexual abuse by a member of the clergy. The court, however, did dismiss two paragraphs of the complaint which would have required it to decide disputed issues of religious doctrine and practice.