Friday, October 04, 2013

NY Methodist Hospital Not Religious Institution For Ministerial Exception Doctrine or RFRA

Penn v. New York Methodist Hospital, 2013 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 142109 (SD NY, Sept. 30, 2013), is in part a Title VII discrimination and retaliation lawsuit by a former part-time staff chaplain at New York Methodist Hospital. Among its defenses, the hospital asserted the ministerial exception doctrine. The court rejected the defense however because of a lack of evidence that the hospital is a religious institution or is religiously affiliated. In 1975, the hospital had amended its articles of incorporation to delete provisions relating to its relationship with The United Methodist Church.  For the same reason, the Religious Freedom Restoration Act does not bar commencement of the action.