Court Orders Florida Prisons To Provide Kosher Diet Alternative

In an important prisoner free exercise decision last week, a federal district court granted a preliminary injunction ordering the Florida Department of Corrections to provide a kosher diet by July 1 to all prisoners with a sincere religious basis for keeping kosher.  The decision comes in what appears to be the first Justice Department suit directly against a state for violation of the prisoner provisions of the Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act. In United States v. Secretary, Florida Department of Corrections, (SD FL, Dec. 6, 2013), the court held that the United States was likely to prevail on the merits of its claim that Florida's religious diet policy violates RLUIPA.

The court held that Florida had not shown a compelling interest in a blanket denial of kosher food to prisoners-- in part because the state argued somewhat inconsistently that it was committed to providing kosher meals to all eligible inmates. The court also rejected Florida's argument that it had a compelling interest based on cost savings, saying:

While cost control may be a compelling interest in certain situations ... RLUIPA expressly contemplates that facilitating religious exercise "may require a government to incur expenses in its own operations.''.... The costs initially identifed by Defendants in this litigation are not of a compelling magnitude.... Even if participation were ... 1,000 prisoners per day - the cost would only be $2.12 million per year, or .001 of FDOC'S budget. No compelling interest is furthered by avoiding such a relatively minor expense....

The court additionally held invalid several provisions in a proposed religious diet program that the state had developed while the litigation was pending.  These include conditioning eligibility on clergy interpretations of religious doctrine or on prisoners' knowledge of religious law; summary suspension of prisoners from the program if they consume any item not listed as kosher; and removal from the program of prisoners who eat less than 90% of available meals, even if they consume only kosher food.  (See prior related posting.) [Thanks to Luke Goodrich for the lead.]