Saturday, March 22, 2014

District Court Invalidates Michigan Ban on Same-Sex Marriage; 6th Circuit Stays Order

In DeBoer v. Snyder, (ED MI, March 21, 2014), a Michigan federal district court held that Michigan's state constitutional ban on same-sex marriage violates the 14th Amendment's equal protection clause.  The case began as a constitutional challenge to Michigan's adoption laws which only allow single persons or married couples to adopt.  Plaintiffs were a same-sex couple who were precluded from marrying under Michigan law.  The court invited plaintiffs to amend their complaint to challenge the Michigan Marriage Amendment which the court saw as the underlying reason plaintiffs could not jointly adopt children. Plaintiffs did so, and the court held a two-week trial, largely devoted to expert testimony about whether children raised by heterosexual parents did better than those raised by same-sex couples. The court's opinion discusses the expert testimony at length, ultimately concluding that the state has no rational basis for preventing same-sex couples from marrying. ACLU of Michigan issued a press release announcing the decision.

Ten minutes after the district court's March 21 opinion was handed down, Michigan state attorney general Bill Schuette filed an emergency motion asking the 6th Circuit to stay the district court's order, pending appeal. (Detroit Free Press.) On March 22, the 6th Circuit issued an order directing plaintiffs to respond by March 25, and a second order temporarily staying the district court's judgment until March 26 "to allow a more reasoned consideration of the motion."

Meanwhile, clerk's offices in four Michigan counties opened Saturday morning to allow same-sex couples to obtain licenses, and, according to AP, over 300 licenses were issued before the 6th Circuit called a halt to their issuance by its stay.  The attorney general's office declined to say whether the state would recognize these marriages, saying "the courts will have to sort it out."