Saturday, May 30, 2020

TRO Denied In Church's Challenge To Delaware COVID-19 Order

In Bullock v. Carney(D DE, May 29, 2020), a Delaware federal district court refused to issue a temporary restraining order to the pastor of Canaan Baptist Church who objected to Delaware Governor John Carney's COVID-19 restrictions on worship services. The court refused the TRO in part because the governor's restrictions had been liberalized by a May 23 order. Additionally the court said:
... Dr. Bullock's counsel argued that his client would be irreparably harmed as a result of three restrictions imposed by the May 23rd Guidance: (1) the requirement that preachers wear a mask while preaching; (2) the requirement that the pastor ( or anyone else) not hold a person during the course of the person's baptism; and (3) certain requirements that relate to the preparation and distribution of communion.... There is, however, no record evidence to support these assertions, and attorney argument cannot establish a showing of irreparable harm.
The court added:
[M]y decision today has no bearing on the merits of Dr. Bullock's claims. Those claims implicate one of our most treasured rights protected by the Constitution-the right to exercise freely one's religion. And they implicate as well the fundamental right of a state "to protect itself against an epidemic of disease which threatens the safety of its members.".... These important principles make this an important case, and my decision today will afford me the opportunity to give the case the considered reflection it deserves.
Delaware News Journal reports on the decision.