Wednesday, August 31, 2022

Michigan Abortion Rights Amendment Faces Possible Ballot Exclusion Because of Typographical Formatting Errors

Earlier today, the Michigan Board of State Canvassers deadlocked 2-2, along party lines, in its vote on approving for inclusion on the November ballot an abortion rights state constitutional amendment. As reported by the Detroit Free Press, while backers had obtained far more than the minimum number of petition signatures need for inclusion on the ballot, challengers focused on the formatting of the text of the proposed amendment on the petition which erroneously ran several words together so that there were no spaces between the words. The Board of State Canvassers staff report said in part:

The Michigan Constitution of 1963 requires that the “petition shall include the full text of the proposed amendment”....

The RFFA petition includes the same letters, arranged in the same order, as the petition conditionally approved at the March 23rd Board meeting... Certain portions of the petition have smaller spaces between words; the spacing between words in some instances appears similar to the spacing between letters within words. The Michigan Election Law is silent on the amount of space that must be between letters and words in a petition.

Challengers argued that because of these typographical errors, the petitions do not contain the full text of the proposed amendment.

Under MCL §168.479, a decision of the Board of State Canvassers may be challenged by a petition filed with the state Supreme Court within 7 days of the decision. The group sponsoring the amendment, Reproductive Freedom For All, has already announced that it will appeal to the Michigan Supreme Court.