Objective coverage of church-state and religious liberty developments, with extensive links to primary sources.
Thursday, January 11, 2007
Rehearing and En Banc Review Sought In Boy Scouts Case
As previously reported, on December 18, 2006, in order to avoid deciding a federal constitutional question, the U.S. 9th Circuit Court of Appeals certified three questions to the California Supreme Court in Barnes-Wallace v. Boy Scouts of America. The lawsuit challenges the constitutionality of the City of San Diego's leasing, at nominal rentals, to the Boy Scouts city property on which the Scouts operate a campground and aquatic center. The 9th Circuit asked the California court to consider whether the leases, under state law, unconstitutionally provide support for a creed. However, on December 26, the 9th Circuit issued another order requesting the California Supreme Court to delay considering the certified questions because a 9th Circuit judge had filed a notice that might lead to en banc review. In a press release issued last week, the Boy Scouts revealed that they had filed a petition for rehearing and for en banc review with the 9th Circuit. The petition to the 9th Circuit (full text) argues that the panel majority's decision on standing was in conflict with controlling US Supreme Court decisions, and that it ignored the procedural posture of the case and failed to include the facts necessary for an informed resolution of the certified questions. [Thanks to How Appealing for the lead.]
House of Lords Refuses To Reject Sexual Orientation Anti-Discrimination Rules
Despite demonstrations and pressure from Christians, on Tuesday the House of Lords defeated a motion to reject Northern Ireland's Sexual Orientation Regulations. Gay.com reported yesterday that the Lords voted 199 - 68 to reject a motion by Lord Morrow who had argued that "the regulations threaten to override the conscience and free speech of Christians". (See prior related posting.)
Bus Company Sued By Employees For Religious Discrimination
Yesterday's Minneapolis Star Tribune reported that nine current and former employees of MV Transportation Inc. have filed a religious discrimination suit under both state and federal law in federal district court in Minneapolis. Among the allegations are that an MV manager read Bible passages to the employees, seven of whom are Muslim, confiscated their prayer rugs and forced them to listen to loud Christian music. The suit also alleges various acts of national origin discrimination. The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission investigated the employees' complaints and issued "right to sue" notices to them.
Egyptian Official Opposes Wearing of Niqab
Middle East Online yesterday reported that an aide to Egypt's Minister of Religious Endowments expelled a religious counselor attending a training session for religious advisors and prayer leaders because she refused to remove her niqab (full face veil). Minister Hamdi Zaqzuq, who opened the training session, later said: "I totally reject the niqab (face veil). No religious counselor needs to wear it since it is not required by Islamic law."
Wednesday, January 10, 2007
No Tax Exemption For Combined Synagogue- Living Quarters
In Sephardic Congregation of S. Monsey v Town of Ramapo, (Sup Ct Rockland Co. NY, Jan. 8, 2007), a New York state trial court has held that property owned by s Sephardic Jewish congregation and used both as its synagogue and as a residence for its rabbi is not tax exempt. Because the property is not used primarily for religious services, it is not exempt under RPTL 420-a. Because the rabbi has full-time outside employment as a special education teacher at a school, Yeshiva of North Jersey, he is only a part-time clergyman for the synagogue and, as such, the residence is not exempt as a parsonage under RPTL 462. Today's Lower Hudson Journal News covers the decision.
Litigation Looms Over Property of Breakaway Anglican Churches In Virginia
After nine Virginia Episcopal congregations voted last month to break away from the Episcopal Church of the United States and affiliate instead with the Anglican Church of Nigeria (see prior posting), they signed an agreement with the Episcopal Diocese of Virginia in which both sides pledged not to bring litigation over church property. The 30-day standstill agreement would automatically renew unless either side opted out. Today's Washington Post reports that the Diocese of Virginia, saying that the churches are not interested in working on a compromise, has now elected not to renew the agreement. It is planning-- after the initial agreement's expiration next Wednesday-- to take steps to claim the property of all nine churches while it is considering each church's situation on a case by case basis. Some of the nine churches are refusing to permit congregants who opposed the break off to hold their own separate services on church premises.
Italian Bishop Criticizes Proposed Law On Religious Equality
Giuseppe Betori, the secretary of the Italian Bishops' Conference, spoke out today in opposition to a draft law being considered by the Italian Parliament that would grant equal rights to all religious faiths in predominately Catholic Italy. Even though Catholicism is no longer the official state religion in Italy, it still enjoys some preferences. AKI says Betori told Parliament's Commission on Constitutional Affairs: "In the current constitutional context, the equal freedom of each confession does not imply full equality. The state should be careful not to sign too many agreements."
VA's Spirituality Assessment of Patients Does Not Violate Establishment Clause
On Monday, according to the Associated Press, a Wisconsin federal district court rejected an Establishment Clause challenge to the Veterans Administration practice of giving most patients spiritual assessments that include questions about their religious observance as part of a holistic treatment program. The VA says it believes that spirituality should be integrated into health care, but it allows patients to decide whether that involves religion. The court concluded that the VA program serves a valid secular purpose. The opinion said: "The choice to receive spiritual or pastoral care, the choice to complete a spiritual assessment, and the choice to participate in a religious or spiritually based treatment program always remain the private choice of the veteran. Accordingly, there is no evidence of governmental indoctrination of religion." (See prior related posting.)
The case was brought by the Freedom From Religion Foundation. The Madison (WI) Capital Times quotes FFRF spokesperson Annie Laurie Gaylor who criticized the judge's decision: "He just didn't get it. Part of his decision stated that VA chaplains are there to bring healing through God's grace and he said it without putting it in quotes. Does his courtroom operate that way, too?"
UPDATE: The full opinion in Freedom From Religion Foundation , Inc. v. Nicholson,(WD WI, Jan. 8, 2007) is now available online. Also BBS reported on Thursday that FFRF will appeal the district court's ruling.
The case was brought by the Freedom From Religion Foundation. The Madison (WI) Capital Times quotes FFRF spokesperson Annie Laurie Gaylor who criticized the judge's decision: "He just didn't get it. Part of his decision stated that VA chaplains are there to bring healing through God's grace and he said it without putting it in quotes. Does his courtroom operate that way, too?"
UPDATE: The full opinion in Freedom From Religion Foundation , Inc. v. Nicholson,(WD WI, Jan. 8, 2007) is now available online. Also BBS reported on Thursday that FFRF will appeal the district court's ruling.
Controversial Navy Chaplain's Discharge Upheld
After having previously refusing to grant a temporary restraining order (see prior posting), last week, according to yesterday's Navy Times, a federal district court in the District of Columbia refused to grant an injunction to Navy Chaplain Gordon J. Klingenschmitt to keep him in the Navy beyond his January 31 discharge date. The controversial Chaplain who has been challenging the Navy's policy on sectarian prayers by chaplains resigned from the Evangelical Episcopal Church and obtained a new endorsement as a chaplain from the Full Gospel Church. The Navy treated this as a new application and rejected it. Klingenschmitt claims that the Navy has permitted as many as 42 other chaplains to change endorsers without losing their positions.
UPDATE: On January 24, the Air Force Times reported that Klingenschmitt asked the Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit to reconsider the district court's denial of an injunction to prevent his discharge.
UPDATE: On January 24, the Air Force Times reported that Klingenschmitt asked the Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit to reconsider the district court's denial of an injunction to prevent his discharge.
Arizona Supreme Court Rejects Original Jurisdiction In School Voucher Challenge
Without comment yesterday, the Arizona Supreme Court refused to hear a challenge to two new state tuition grant programs offering school vouchers to foster parents and parents of disabled children. The ACLU and People for the American Way brought the challenge directly in the state Supreme Court claiming that the programs violate state constitutional prohibitions against public funding for private and religious schools. Reporting on the decision, the Associated Press said that plaintiffs can now refile the case in a trial court. Praising the court's decision, the Institute for Justice said that judicial precedent indicates that the voucher programs are constitutional. In a press release it said: "School choice opponents should stop their legal battle against programs that simply empower parents choose the educational environment that best suits their children."
North Carolina Pastor Seeking Support For Christian Prayer At City Council
In Thomasville, North Carolina, Rev. Donnie Lunsford was concerned that only 50 people turned out for a City Council meeting last month at which City Councilman Dwight Cornelison proposed including Christian prayers at Council meetings. So Lunsford is planning a Feb. 3 breakfast billed as a "Christian involvement conference" to increase support for Cornelison's proposal, according to yesterday's Lexington (NC) Dispatch. Cornelison is attempting to create a policy that will both allow Christian prayer and pass Constitutional scrutiny. He says that options are offering invocations before meetings are officially called to order; having council members pray only for themselves instead of on behalf of the entire city; or to inviting clergy on a rotating basis from various faiths. Councilman Cornelison supporting Rev. Lunsford's "involvement conference" said: "We're going to dispel the rumors that Christians can't be involved.... God ordained government, church and the family. It's a Christian duty and obligation to participate in civil government."
Tuesday, January 09, 2007
Maryland Non-Public Schools Seek Additional State Aid
The Maryland Catholic Conference and the Maryland Nonpublic Schools Legislative Coalition hosted a series of conferences around the state on Monday to build support for proposals to increase Maryland funding for non-public schools. Southern Maryland Online today reports that the groups' legislative goals for 2007 are (1) to increase funding for the Nonpublic School Textbook and Technology Program; (2) to include nonpublic school teachers in benefits already available to public school teachers, such as teacher scholarships and the Quality Teacher Incentive Tax Credit; and (3) to enact a Maryland tax credit for businesses who contribute to both public and nonpublic schools.
Michigan School Board Rejects Bible As Literature Class
After lengthy testimony on both sides of the issue at a Board of Education meeting, the Howell, Michigan Board of Education decided against offering a class on the Bible as literature in its school system. Today's Livingston (MI) Press & Argus reports that the motion to approve the curriculum made by board member Wendy Day died for want of a second. A committee of the social study teachers had decided not to recommend the new course because a world religion course already covers the same areas.
Cert. Denied In Case On Invalidating Donations To Churches By Debtor In Bankruptcy
Yesterday the United States Supreme Court denied certiorari in Universal Church v. Geltzer, (Case No. 06-583), in which the 2nd Circuit Court of Appeals had held that treating some contributions to churches as fraudulent conveyances in bankruptcy does not violate the Free Exercise or Establishment clauses. It also held that under the Religious Liberty and Charitable Donations Protection Act the shield for charitable donations of up to 15% of a debtor's annual income applies to aggregate annual transfers, not to individual donations. (See prior posting.)
Now It's Harder To Deduct Charitable Contributions
Religion News Service reported yesterday that new Internal Revenue Service requirements that became effective on January 1 will make it more difficult for taxpayers to deduct contributions placed anonymously in the church collection basket. The requirements, contained in the Pension Protection Act of 2006, Sec. 1217, call for a cancelled check, bank record, credit card record or receipt from a charity in order to claim an amount as a charitable deduction. In the past, personal records were sufficient to document the contribution if it was under $250. The IRS explained the new rules in a December news release.
Monday, January 08, 2007
Religious Coalitions Weigh In On Immigration; Education
As the new Congress opened, religious coalitions weighed in on two important issues. Today's Washington Times reports that a coalition made up mostly of conservative Christian groups has proposed a compromise on immigration reform. The coalition, known as Families First On Immigration, sent letters to President Bush and Congressional leaders urging strong border security and amnesty for aliens already here illegally if they have an American-born child or another relative who is a citizen. Finally the compromise calls for an end to citizenship merely because an individual is born in the United States-- though this part of the proposal might require a Constitutional amendment. The group urged President Bush to defer his guest worker proposals until the rest of the issues are resolved. It also urged Congressional Democrats to exercise oversight on the Administration's handling of immigration.
Meanwhile, a separate coalition of 100 religious, civil rights, educational and disability organizations known as the Forum on Educational Accountability has taken the occasion of the fifth anniversary of the No Child Left Behind Act to urge some 14 changes to the law. (ABCUSA Press Release.) Among these are calls for less reliance on standardized testing and increased federal funding of costs that will be imposed on states by the recommendations.
Meanwhile, a separate coalition of 100 religious, civil rights, educational and disability organizations known as the Forum on Educational Accountability has taken the occasion of the fifth anniversary of the No Child Left Behind Act to urge some 14 changes to the law. (ABCUSA Press Release.) Among these are calls for less reliance on standardized testing and increased federal funding of costs that will be imposed on states by the recommendations.
Romney's Mormonism Remains A Factor In His Presidential Bid
The McClatchy Newspapers yesterday examined how Protestant conservatives in the Republican Party are reacting to presidential hopeful Mitt Romney's Mormon religious beliefs. Some voters remain concerned about now-rejected beliefs of the Mormon Church-- its advocacy of polygamy and its belief that Blacks were cursed. Others are concerned about Mormonism's present-day beliefs, such as its openness to modern-day prophecies and its belief that the church president is "the mouthpiece of God." Some conservatives worry that Romney is too liberal, citing his support of equal rights for gays and lesbians in his unsuccessful 1994 bid for the U.S. Senate. A report by CNS News last week focused on the concern over whether Romney has been consistent in his conservative views on homosexuality and abortion.
Satirical Attack On Intelligent Design Becomes Popular
Yesterday's Toronto Star carries an article on a satirical challenge to supporters of Intelligent Design which has caught on. Bobby Henderson, a 26-year-old physics graduate from Oregon State University, in 2005 wrote that the earth and all living things were created by a Supreme Being, the Flying Spaghetti Monster. Last March he published a book, The Gospel of the Flying Spaghetti Monster, (Villard, 2006), and he has launched a website that includes his "Open Letter to Kansas School Board" requesting that his theory be taught as an alternative version of Intelligent Design. Apparently the site gets 30,000 unique visits per day. The FSM movement has its own subculture of "Pastafarians". Some proponents of Intelligent Design, however, do not completely appreciate the humor. Last month, the Discovery Institute's website attacked FSM as mocking those who hold Judeo-Christian religion beliefs, saying that FSM is reportedly endorsed by 50 Darwinist academics.
Sunday, January 07, 2007
Faith-Based Welfare Poses Discrimination Issues In Britain
Britain is now struggling with issues similar to those in the U.S. on the offering of social services by faith-based organizations. Britain's National Secular Society reports today that it has asked Parliament's Human Rights Committee to recommend clarifying the Human Rights Act, Sec. 6, to ensure that when a public body delegates social service functions to a private organization, protections against discrimination based on religious belief or sexual orientation still apply. Both Labour and Conservatives in Britain are promoting faith-based welfare programs.
French Appeals Court Says Pork Soup To Homeless Is Discriminatory
MWC yesterday reported that a ban by Paris police on the serving of pork soup to the homeless has now been upheld by France's highest administrative court, the Conseil d'Etat. A lower court had overturned the police determination that the right wing soup kitchens were discriminating against Muslims and Jews. (See prior posting.) However the French interior ministry successfully appealed. The appeals court confirmed the police ban on Friday, holding that it did not infringe freedom of expression. Paris mayor Bertrand Delanoe praised the decision.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)