Objective coverage of church-state and religious liberty developments, with extensive links to primary sources.
Sunday, June 10, 2007
Rabbi's Contract and ADA Claims Dismissed On 1st Amendment Grounds
Saturday, June 09, 2007
US President Meets Pope In Rome
While in Rome, Bush also met at the U.S. Embassy with members of the Sant Egido Community, a lay Roman Catholic organization that operates an AIDS program in ten African countries. The program is partly funded by the U.S. Listening to the group’s concerns, Bush said that he would look into making it easier for faith based groups to access US aid funds directly, instead of through foreign governments.I'll be glad to share some of the private conversation with His Holy Father. First, I'll give you an impression. I was talking to a very smart, loving man…. I was in awe, and it was a moving experience for me.
… He did express deep concern about the Christians inside Iraq, that he was concerned that the society that was evolving would not tolerate the Christian religion. And I assured him we're working hard to make sure that people lived up to the constitution, the modern constitution voted on by the people that would honor people from different walks of life and different attitudes.
… We talked about our attempts to help the people on Africa deal with HIV/AIDS and malaria and hunger. I reminded him that we made a significant commitment to that end…
And I talked to him about our attempts to feed the hungry, and I also reminded him that we've got poor people in our own neighborhood that need to be affected. He talked about immigration. He's watching the immigration debate very closely in America. And I told him I was a person who strongly supports comprehensive immigration reform; that, on the one hand, we'll enforce our law, on the other hand, we need to treat people with dignity. And we had a good discussion.…
Q The Pope has said Iraq was worrisome.
PRESIDENT BUSH: Yes, he's worrisome [sic] about the Christians inside Iraq being mistreated by the Muslim majority. He's deeply concerned about that, and we spent a lot -- spent a fair amount of time talking about it.
Congress Hears Varied Religious Views On Attacking Global Warming
Egyptian Court Upholds Right To Wear Niqab On Campus
Canadian AG Concerned That Polygamy Charges Will Raise Religious Freedom Issues
Free Exercise Challenge To Restriction On Feeding Needy Rejected
Friday, June 08, 2007
West Virginia Justice Reveals Religious Attacks Against Him In Campaign
School Will Not Appeal Religious Flier Case
District Court Rejects Challenge To Suspension of Bussing To Parochial School
Plaintiffs claimed that provisions of the South Dakota constitution prohibiting aid for religious schools violated their federal constitutional rights. The court, however, concluded that "Whether the S.D. Constitution provisions are either facially discriminatory or were adopted out of religious animus does not matter because plaintiffs cannot establish a causal link between the S.D. Constitution provisions and the School District policy."
The court found that the school district's delay in reinstituting busing once state law was amended to permit it and insurance concerns were resolved was motivated by its concern over how that action would affect pending litigation. The court went on to say: "Because School District’s continued denial of busing is rationally related to a legitimate government interest, plaintiffs’ free exercise challenge fails as a matter of law. Further, even if School District’s policy was not facially neutral, the Supreme Court’s decision in Locke v. Davey,... indicates that the denial of busing is too insignificant of a burden to constitute a free exercise violation."
Today's Sioux Falls Argus Leader reports on the decision and the reaction of both sides to the decision.
Suburban Chicago Church Loses RLUIPA Challenge In 7th Circuit
The court also rejected the claim that the church had a vested right to operate in the warehouse because the initial refusal of a permit was under a zoning ordinance that discriminated against religious institutions. Subsequently the ordinance was revised to exclude all membership organizations-- not just churches-- from industrial zones. Posner wrote: "If the 1988 ordinance violated RLUIPA, as Northbrook comes close to conceding, Petra didn't have to comply with it. But that doesn't mean that it acquired an immunity from all zoning regulation. It knew or should have known that Northbrook could redo its ordinance to comply with the "less than equal terms" provision of RLUIPA...."
Judge Refuses To Dismiss Defamation Suit Against Funeral Picketers
Muslim Correctional Officer Trainee Loses Free Exercise Claim
Bipartisan Bill In Congress Would Require Pharmacies To Fill Contraceptive Requests
Summary Judgment Denied In Preachers' Challenge To LA Town Over Protest Rights
Thursday, June 07, 2007
Religion In US Politics Fascinates Writer In India
I want [New York Mayor Michael] Bloomberg to campaign for president because it would be a political experiment, one that tests the proposition that a serious candidate for the American presidency needs to be a Christian. And not just a nominal Christian but an observant Christian. As an Indian interested in the role of religion and religious identity in politics, I’d like to know if a non-Christian like Mr Bloomberg (who is Jewish), can mount a credible campaign. For this proposition to be disproved, it isn't important that Bloomberg win: merely that he be taken seriously as a presidential candidate.
Being publicly Christian seems oddly important in American politics. Oddly important because the democracy Indians live in, despite its bloody record of sectarian intolerance and violence, routinely elects non-believing Hindus and non-Hindus to high political office.