7th Circuit Holds No Damage Claims Against States Under RLUIPA

In Nelson v. Miller, (7th Cir., July 1, 2009), the 7th Circuit joined the 4th and 5th Circuits in holding tht states did not waive their sovereign immunity for damage actions in prisoner claims under RLUIPA by accepting federal funds. The 11th Circuit has taken an opposite position. The 7th Circuit also held in the case that RLUIPA -- enacted under Congress' spending clause powers--does not authorized damage claims against state officials in their individual capacities since they were not recipients of state funds. It remanded for further findings on whether Illinois had a compelling interest a prisoner's complaint regarding denial of a non-meat diet.

Liberal Christian Groups Increase Activism on Public Issues

The Wall Street Journal today reports on a new political activism by progressive and liberal Christians. For example, a recent ad campaign by the American Values Network on Christian and country music stations in ten states encouraged support for federal legislation to limit greenhouse gas emissions, framing support in religious terms. Another coalition of Christian groups is about to begin an ad campaign supporting health care reform. Conservative Christian groups, such as the Cornwall Alliance for the Stewardship of Creation which rejects concerns about global warming, are organizing in opposition. [Thanks to Steven H. Sholk for the lead.]

Religious Groups Kept Out of Challenge To Canadian Prostitution Laws

In Canada, an Ontario trial court judge has refused to permit the Christian Legal Fellowship and the Catholic Civil Rights League (as well as a conservative women's group, REAL Women of Canada) to intervene in a case challenging the constitutionality of several of Ontario's anti-prostitution laws. Today's Toronto Globe and Mail reports that the court gave several related reasons for denying standing to the groups. It feared they would prolong and disrupt the trial and would be presenting contentious moral views that reflect only a small part of Canadian society.

Obama Meets With Catholic Press Ahead of Vatican Visit

Yesterday President Barack Obama met with eight members of the Catholic press ahead of his planned meeting with Pope Benedict XVI next Friday. Obama will be in Italy for the Group of Eight meeting after visiting Russia earlier in the week. (AFP report on trip.) Obama opened the White House meeting with media with a statement and then answered questions from each reporter. The National Catholic Register has a series of reports on questions asked. Most attention has been given to Obama's statement that "there will be a robust conscience clause in place" when the White House finishes its review of HHS regulations that were put in place at the end of the Bush administration. Obama promised that the conscience protections will not be weaker than those that were in place before the Bush changes. The President also responded to questions on abortion rights, tensions between liberal and conservative Catholics, his own choice of a new church, homosexual rights, and the Middle East.

Final Rules for British Teachers Modified After Religious Objections To Diversity Standards

On Wednesday, the General Teaching Council for England announced the adoption of a new Code of Conduct and Practice for Registered Teachers. It contains 8 principles aimed at helping children learn and promoting cooperation with other professionals and parents. The original draft of the Code published for comment last November drew objections from Christian and other religious groups that argued the mandate to "promote equality and value diversity" would require teachers to promote homosexuality in violation of their religious beliefs. (See prior posting.) Substantial changes in response to these concerns were made in the final draft. According to yesterday's Guardian, "the new version of the code ... has been radically reworded to take out requirements to 'promote' diversity. Teachers no longer have to 'proactively challenge' discrimination and are instead simply required to address it...."

Court In India Strikes Down Law Banning Consensual Adult Homsexual Relations

In India, the Delhi High Court today struck down as unconstitutional Section 377 of the Indian Penal Code insofar as it bans homosexual sexual acts in private between consenting adults. (Background.) In a 105-page opinion in Naz Foundation v. Government of NCT of Delhi, (High Ct. Delhi, July 2, 2009), the court cites extensively not just to Indian precedent, but to that in the U.S. Britain and other Commonwealth countries. The court concluded that the challenged provision, infringes the right to privacy guaranteed by Section 21 of India's Constitution as well as Section 14 (equality before the law) and 15 (discrimination on the basis of sex) of the Indian Constitution. It writes:

If there is one constitutional tenet that can be said to be underlying theme of the Indian Constitution, it is that of 'inclusiveness'. This Court believes that Indian Constitution reflects this value deeply ingrained in Indian society, nurtured over several generations. The inclusiveness that Indian society traditionally displayed, literally in every aspect of life, is manifest in recognising a role in society for everyone. Those perceived by the majority as “deviants' or 'different' are not on that score excluded or ostracised.

Where society can display inclusiveness and understanding, such persons can be assured of a life of dignity and nondiscrimination. ..... In our view, Indian Constitutional law does not permit the statutory criminal law to be held captive by the popular misconceptions of who the LGBTs are. It cannot be forgotten that discrimination is antithesis of equality and that it is the recognition of equality which will foster the dignity of every individual.

The law at issue was enacted in the 19th century when India was a British colony. The challenge was brought by a group working on HIV/AIDS prevention. The court described petitioner's contentions, in part, as follows:

Section 377 IPC is based upon traditional Judeo-Christian moral and ethical standards, which conceive of sex in purely functional terms, i.e., for the purpose of procreation only. Any non-procreative sexual activity is thus viewed as being "against the order of nature”. The submission is that the legislation criminalising consensual oral and anal sex is outdated and has no place in modern society.... Section 377 IPC serves as the weapon for police abuse; detaining and questioning, extortion, harassment, forced sex, payment of hush money; and perpetuates negative and discriminatory beliefs towards same-sex relations and sexuality minorities; which consequently drive the activities of gay men and MSM, as well as sexuality minorities underground thereby crippling HIV/AIDS prevention efforts.

Bloomberg today reports on the court's decision. Indian Express reports on the reactions of various religious leaders in India to the decision.

Fiduciary and Arizona AG Oppose Proposed UEP Trust Settlement

Reports from KSL News and Dallas Morning News yesterday indicate renewed disagreement over how to reform the United Effort Plan Trust which holds property of FLDS church. Last month, Utah's attorney general proposed a settlement in the proceedings in which a Utah court is attempting to reform the trust. (See prior posting.) Responses filed yesterday indicate that the settlement proposal is supported by the FLDS church, but is opposed by Arizona's attorney general and court-appointed special fiduciary Bruce Wisan. Wisan objects that the proposed settlement excessively favors current FLDS members over former members. The proposed settlement would set aside an area in Colorado City, Arizona, for former FLDS members who left the Church voluntarily or through excommunication. The Arizona Attorney General says this creates religious segregation. Wisan's attorneys also raise questions regarding who can speak for the FLDS church.

New York City Council Wants Muslim Holidays On School Calendar

New York's city council on Tuesday passed a resolution adding two Muslim holidays-- Id al-Fitr and Id al-Adha-- to the school calendar. However, according to the New York Times, under current law Mayor Michael Bloomberg has the final say over which days are school holidays, at least if the legislature extends Bloomberg's expiring control over the schools. Bloomberg opposes adding these days off. Council also urged the state legislature to pass pending legislation that would require schools be closed for these holidays. [Thanks to Alliance Alert for the lead.]

Coleman's Defeat Means No Jewish Republicans In U.S. Senate

With Al Franken's defeat of Norm Coleman in Minnesota, the Republicans are without any Jewish members of the U.S. Senate for the first time since 1957. That was the year Jacob Javits became New York's senator. CBS News points out that there is only one Jewish Republican in the House of Representatives-- minority whip Eric Cantor. In contrast, there are 13 Jewish Democrats in the Senate (including newly-elected Al Franken) and 29 Jewish Democrats in the House.

CAIR Will Distribute 100,000 Qurans To U.S. Leaders

At a news conference yesterday, the Council on American-Islamic Relations announced Phase II its "Share the Quran" campaign. According to the New York Times, CAIR plans to distribute 100,000 copies of the Quran to local, state and national leaders, including President Barack Obama who will be given one as a thank-you for his speech to the Muslim world. CAIR hopes to distribute 1 million copies of the Quran to the American public over the next ten years.

Connecticut AG Says Ethics Agency Should Drop Investigation of Diocese Lobbying

Connecticut Attorney General Richard Blumenthal has advised the Office of State Ethics to drop its investigation of whether activities of the Bridgeport Diocese require it to register as a lobbyist. The state ethics office wrote the Diocese raising questions after the Diocese took part in a rally in March opposing Raised Bill 1098 that would have forced reorganization of financial oversight in Catholic parishes. The Diocese then sued in federal court to stop state action to force it to register. (See prior posting.) Yesterday's Hartford Courant reports that Blumenthal believes the investigation and enforcement activities against the Diocese may raise church-state concerns, and says the legislature needs to narrow and clarify the statute. While the ethics agency can still proceed, Blumenthal's office is refusing to defend its actions. Individual agency officials might face damage claims.

UPDATE: The Hartford Courant reports that on Wednesday afternoon, the Office of State Ethics dropped it investigation of the Bridgeport Catholic Diocese.

UPDATE 2: On Thursday afternoon, the Bridgeport Diocese announced it was dropping its federal lawsuit. (Connecticut Post.)

Azerbaijan Places New Limits On Choice of Muslim Religious Leaders

Forum 18 reports that Azerbaijan's Parliament (the Milli Mejlis) yesterday adopted two new amendments to the country's Religion Law. The new provisions impact only the Muslim community. An amendment to Article 8 provides that all religious functionaries who lead Islamic places of prayer must be appointed by the Caucasian Muslim Board with approval of the government's executive officials. An amendment to Article 21 requires that: "The performance of religious rituals of the Islamic faith can be carried out only by citizens of Azerbaijan who have received their education in Azerbaijan." The bill now goes to the country's President who has 56 days to sign it or return it to Parliament. Presidential approval is expected quickly.

Pastor Will Lead Prayer In Pennsylvania Senate After Rejecting House's Rules

The Pennsylvania House of Representatives invites clergy to offer an opening prayer, but requires the prayer to be submitted in advance. When Rev. Gerry Stoltzfoos was invited and submitted his invocation, a staff member in the Speaker's office requested that he remove a reference to Jesus in the closing. The House has recently adopted this policy to avoid litigation. Rev. Stoltzfoos, however, objected and decided not to accept the invitation to lead the House in prayer, saying: "I just feel like if you want me to pray, then I have to pray to the one thing I know." Now, according to yesterday's York Daily Record, Pennsylvania state Sen. Rich Alloway, who was "shocked" by the House policy, has invited Stoltzfoos to open the state Senate with a prayer-- where no similar editorial policy is in effect. Alloway, commenting on the House policy, said: "This government should not be antagonistic toward any religion."

DC Court Agrees With Election Board: No Referendum On Gay Marriages

In Jackson v. District of Columbia Board of Elections and Ethics, (DC Super. Ct., June 30, 2009), the D.C. Superior Court refused to grant a preliminary injunction to stay the effective date of new legislation in D.C. that would recognize the validity of same-sex marriages performed elsewhere. The court upheld the finding by the Board of Elections that the law is not subject to a referendum because the referendum would violate D.C.'s Human Rights Act. (See prior posting.) In the lawsuit brought by seven D.C. residents led by Bishop Harry R. Jackson of Hope Christian Church in Beltsville (MD), the court said: "A citizen’s disagreement with constitutionally sound legislation, whether based on political, religious or moral views, does not rise to the level of an actionable harm." Today's Washington Times reports on the decision.

Leonard Leo Elected USCIRF Chairman

Leonard Leo, executive vice president of the Federalist Society and a commissioner of the U.S. Commission on International Religious Freedom has been named chairman of USCIRF for a year-long term beginning July 1, according to a USCIRF press release yesterday. Michael Cromartie, vice president of the Ethics and Public Policy Center, and Elizabeth H. Prodromou, professor of International Relations at Boston University, were re-elected as vice-chairs. Leo ws appointed to USCIRF by President George W. Bush in 2007. Under the International Religious Freedom Act, the chair is elected each year by members of the Commission.

Activist Wants Illinois Governor To Veto Appropriations To Religious Institutions

Social activist Rob Sherman has written a top aide to Illinois Governor Pat Quinn urging him to exercise his line item veto to eliminate all grants in the state's recently passed appropriations bill (HB 313) that are directed to churches, parochial schools and other religious organizations. On his blog, Sherman focuses on a grant for infrastructure at St. Martin de Porres Church, a capital improvements grant to St. Malachy School and a grant for construction of a cabin at the Camp Chi. Sherman says the appropriations violate ban in the Illinois constitution on state-mandatessupport for any place of worship., and the ban on spending state funds on parochial schools

Court Refuses To Dismiss RLUIPA Challenge To "Shabbos House"

In Bikur Cholim v. Suffern, 2009 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 54187 (SDNY, June 25, 2009), a New York federal district court refused to dismiss claims under RLUIPA and freedom of association claims challenging the denial of a zoning variance for a Suffern (NY) "Shabbos House." The facility provides overnight accommodations for Jews unable to travel on the Sabbath who wish to visit patients at Suffern's Good Samaritan Hospital. Complaints had been filed by private plaintiffs and also by the federal government alleging RLUIPA and other violations. The court concluded that: "Rabbi [Simon] Lauber's administration of the Shabbos House and private plaintiffs' utilizing the Shabbos House constitute 'religious exercise' under RLUIPA. As to all other elements of the RLUIPA claims, these remain for the factfinder." The court dismissed plaintiffs' equal protection claim.

Appeal Filed With 5th Circuit In Elementary School Hair Style Limits

Fort Bend Now reported yesterday that the Needville, Texas Independent School District has filed an appeal with the U.S. 5th Circuit in A.A. v. Needville Independent School District. In the case, a Texas federal district court granted a permanent injunction preventing an elementary school from enforcing the school district's hair style policy against a 5-year old whose family taught him to wear his hair in two long braids in the tradition of Native American religions. (See prior posting.)

Paper Complains That Mandated Free Day At Holy Land Experience Too Narrowly Advertised

In 2006, the Florida legislature passed a law assuring a property tax exemption for Holy Land Experience religious theme park-- assuring it a tax savings of about $300,000 per year. In order to keep the exemption, Holy Land was required by the law to offer one free-admission day per year. Yesterday's Orlando Sentinel complained that Holy Land only advertises the date of the free-day on the local Trinity Broadcasting Network channel-- WTGL--TV58. The date varies widely each year. Holy Land says that it has a capacity of only 1700, and wider advertising could overwhelm the park.

Israel's High Court Orders Kashrut Certificate For Bakery Owned By Messianic Jew

Israel's High Court of Justice yesterday ordered the Rabbinate in the city of Ashdod to grant a kashrut certificate (kosher certification) to a bakery owned by a Messianic Jew. Haaretz reports that the Chief Rabbinate Council had required bakery owner Pnina Comporati to have enhanced supervision because her beliefs, they felt, meant she could not be trusted to keep her bakery kosher. A 3-judge panel of the High Court ruled, however, that so long as an applicant's beliefs do not themselves affect the kashrut of the food, the Rabbinate has no authority to impose discriminatory requirements based on beliefs.