In United States v. Devero, (3rd Cir., Nov. 18, 2026), the U.S. 3rd Circuit Court of Appeals vacated and remanded to the district court a decision that denied Dontae Devero who had served time on a federal drug charge a modification of the conditions of his supervised release. Devero sought an order that would allow him to smoke marijuana during Rastafarian religious ceremonies and for religious purposes. The district court rejected his argument that the restrictions imposed on him violate his rights under the Religious Freedom Restoration Act. Devero had offered to self-report every time he used marijuana for a religious purpose and submit to regular testing for other drugs. The district court said that "Based on existing legal authority, ... the undersigned cannot in good conscience predict that the Third Circuit will endorse his exception." In remanding the case, the 3rd Circuit said in part:
... [T]he District Court was required to consider Devero’s specific circumstances. And although the District Court assumed without deciding that Devero’s religious request was sincere, reliance on former cases with differently-situated defendants is insufficient under the RFRA’s framework, even if “an overwhelming majority” of those cases do in fact reject Devero’s position. Especially considering that we “ha[ve] not spoken in this specific context,” the District Court’s duty was not to “predict” whether we would endorse his exception; rather, it’s duty was to conduct the analysis in the first instance.