As previously reported, in August the parent body of the United Methodist Church in Texas (the Horizon Texas Conference) filed suit in a Texas state trial court against the 15,000- member Highland Park Methodist congregation in Dallas alleging that the congregation improperly amended its governing documents to eliminate its affiliation with the parent body. This included eliminating the word "United" from its name. As reported by UM News, some 400 members of Highland Park opposed the disaffiliation and continued to worship together at a United Methodist Seminary facility led by a senior pastor appointed by the Horizon Conference. They continued to use the name Highland Park United Methodist Church.
On November 10, the large, disaffiliated congregation filed a counterclaim in the pending lawsuit asking for a temporary restraining order against the small group worshiping as Highland Park United Methodist Church, contending that it has engaged in trademark infringement. According to UM News:
In its countersuit, Highland Park Methodist Church asserted that the use of the names HPUMC and Highland Park for the United Methodist congregation was causing confusion among the public, including donors.
Meanwhile, the conference argued that the designation “United Methodist” is only available to ecclesiastically United Methodist ministries and that “Highland Park” is a geographic designation used by numerous communities including the wealthy neighborhood where both congregations are worshipping.
In Horizon Texas Annual Conference of the United Methodist Church v. Highland Park Methodist Church, Inc., (TX Dist. Ct., Nov. 18, 2026), the court granted the TRO ordering the Horizon Conference not to use the name "Highland Park United Methodist Church" or various derivatives of it, including in soliciting charitable contributions or operating a website. It also barred it from representing that it is affiliated with Highland Park Methodist Church. It added, however:
This Order does not restrain Plaintiff or any person from gathering for worship, or from operating a congregation under any non-infringing name.