In Catholic Charities of Ingham, Eaton & Clinton Counties v. Hertel, (WD MI, Nov. 12, 2026), a Michigan federal district court rejected 1st and 14th Amendment challenges by Catholic Charities to a decision by the Michigan Department of Health and Human Services to disqualify Catholic Charities from receiving funding for Cristo Rey, its counseling center, to offer substance abuse counseling and treatment for pregnant women. Michigan said that the goal of its program is to prevent additional substance-exposed births. To accomplish this, grant recipients are required to promote the effective use of contraceptives and provide referrals for family planning. Offering these options, or referring clients to others to receive them, violates Catholic Charities' religious beliefs.
The court concluded that there was no evidence that Michigan was hostile toward Catholic Charities' beliefs. Rather, Mid-State, the state agency administering the grant program, began an investigation when it learned that Catholic Charities was requiring Cristo Rey employees to sign a new pledge to abide by Catholic values. The court said in part:
,,, [I]n light of MDHHS’s express focus on preventing unwanted pregnancies in clients of the WSS and EWS programs through family planning, effective use of contraceptive methods, and referrals for family planning services, it was entirely reasonable for Mid-State to investigate the impact of the pledge’s restrictions on CCIEC’s ability to serve its clients in compliance with state policies.,,,
Next, CCIEC argues that Mid-State’s Charitable Choice policy is evidence of religious hostility because it applies only to faith-based organizations; it does not require secular organizations to disclose limitations on their services....
CCIEC is correct that Mid-State’s procedure goes farther than what the law requires in terms of its disclosure requirements. And to the extent it does so by requiring the religious entity to disclose their beliefs and resulting service limitations, it puts a greater burden on religious entities than secular ones. But the Court is not persuaded that this deviation is evidence of religious hostility by Mid-State....
CCIEC argues that Defendants violated its right to religious autonomy....
Here, Defendants’ actions do not involve CCIEC’s internal management decisions. They involve CCIEC’s decision not to provide certain contraceptive and related referral and case management services to its external clients. The religious autonomy principle is not implicated here....
CCIEC claims that Defendants’ policies and conduct abridge its right to freedom of speech....
CCIEC argues that Defendants compelled its speech in two ways: (1) by conditioning funding upon changes to CCIEC’s policy and (2) by requiring CCIEC to affirmatively disclose that it cannot provide certain services. But the first does not count as compelled speech....
...As to the disclosure requirement in Mid-State’s Charitable Choice procedure, that requirement was not the basis for MDHHS’s funding decision, so it did not cause any identifiable harm to CCIEC....