Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Spiritual Coercion of Victims Is Sufficient for Charging Sex Trafficking By Force

In September 2025, six members of the La Luz Del Mundo Church, including its current "Apostle," Naasón Joaquín García, were indicted on sex trafficking charges. The Church taught that absolute obedience to the Apostle was required to obtain religious blessings. Using that belief, victims were coerced into engaging in commercial sex acts. (Full text of indictment.) Last week, in United States v. Garcia, (SD NY, Nov. 13, 2026), a New York federal district court rejected Defendants' contentions that the indictment violates the 1st Amendment's Free Exercise Clause and the Religious Freedom Restoration Act. The court said in part:

Defendants argued that the Indictment’s sex trafficking allegations rest on what they term “spiritual coercion” and would require the jury to pass on the truth or falsity of Defendants’ religious beliefs.....

The key statute at issue in this case, 18 U.S.C. § 1591, prohibits sex trafficking accomplished by force, threats of force, fraud, or coercion....

Here, to the extent that the Government proceeds on a theory of coercion under § 1591, such a theory does not require the jury to pass on the truth or falsity of the LLDM Church’s religious teachings.  

Rather, the serious-harm inquiry asks whether the threatened harm would have compelled a reasonable person of the victim’s background and in the victim’s circumstances—i.e., one raised in the LLDM Church who believed its teachings—to engage in commercial sex acts..... 

Núñez Joaquín separately contends that, as a matter of statutory construction, a threat of purely spiritual harm cannot constitute “serious harm” under § 1591....

The Court disagrees.  “Serious harm” expressly includes “nonphysical” and “psychological” harm,...  In any event, the Indictment does not rest on threats of damnation alone.  It also alleges that leaving the Church meant “the end of any relationship with family members or friends inside the LLDM Church”....

Separate from the Free Exercise Clause, Defendants also moved to dismiss the Indictment under the Religious Freedom Restoration Act (“RFRA”).... 

... [C]ompliance with federal sex trafficking statutes does not substantially burden Defendants’ religious practice.  There is no indication that Defendants must threaten or coerce victims into sex acts ... in order to practice their religion or to serve as spiritual leaders.  Section 1591 does not prohibit preaching or the teaching of religious doctrine.  And even if the federal laws at issue did substantially burden Defendants’ religious practice, the Government doubtless has a compelling interest in preventing sex trafficking, whether of children or of adults....