Moussaoui Voir Dire May Include Questions On Jurors' Religion

A Virginia federal district court is expected to begin jury selection in February for a trial that will decide whether Zacarias Moussaoui, the only person charged in the U.S. in the 9-11 terrorist attacks, should receive the death penalty or life in prison. Yesterday, the Associated Press reported that prosecutors have submitted questions that they wish to have asked of potential jurors. Included are questions about a juror's religion, whether the potential juror attends a place of worship and what the individual knows about Islam.

South Carolina City Council Moves To Pre-Meeting Prayer

In Rock Hill, South Carolina, an opening prayer will no longer be listed on the official agenda of city council meetings. Today's Rock Hill Herald reports that instead, council members will pray on a voluntary basis before meetings are called to order. The change is an attempt to prevent lawsuits and comes a month after Councilman Jim Reno created a controversy by closing his official prayer using Jesus' name. A U.S. 4th Circuit Court of Appeals ruling last year barred the town of Great Falls, SC from mentioning Jesus in pre-meeting prayers.

Drug Store Suspends Objecting Pharmacists Because of Illinois Law

Illinois law requires pharmacies to fill all prescriptions on a timely basis. KSDK News reported yesterday that Walgreens has put four Illinois pharmacists on unpaid leave for refusing to fill prescriptions for Plan B, also known as the "morning after pill." The pharmacists say that filling the prescriptions violates their religious beliefs. Walgreens says that refusing to fill the prescriptions places the pharmacy's license at risk.

Sweden's Supreme Court Clears Pastor Who Gave Anti-Gay Sermon

According to PinkNews today, the Supreme Court of Sweden has invoked protections of speech and religion to uphold an appeals court verdict that anti-homosexual remarks in a sermon by Pastor Ake Green could not be prosecuted. The Pentecostal pastor was the first clergyman to be convicted under Sweden's hate crimes law which was amended in 2003 to include attacks against homosexuals.

UPDATE: Further background information, including a transcript of the offending sermon, can be found on this website devoted to the case.

Location Limit on Church's Parolee Facility Upheld

In Pastor Rick Barr v. City of Sinton, a Texas appellate court rejected a minister's state statutory and constitutional claims and upheld a city ordinance that prohibited locating a correctional or rehabilitation facility within 1000 feet of a residential area, school, park or place of worship. Two homes that provide housing for parolees and probationers are operated by Pastor Barr and his corporation, and are located across the street from their sponsoring church. The court rejected the claim that the statute violated plaintiff's free exercise of religion and free speech rights under Art. I, Sec. 6 and 8 of the Texas Constitution and the Texas Religious Freedom Act.

Alabama Bill Would Place "God Bless America" On Auto Tags

The Associated Press reported on Saturday that a bill has been pre-filed in the Alabama legislature by State Rep. Steve Hurst to require most auto license plates to include the phrase "God Bless America". Hurst says, "That will let all the people in America know that we are a Bible Belt state." Carol Moore, president of the Atheist Law Center, said her organization would oppose Hurst's bill. Today's Decatur, Alabama Daily editorializes against the bill, saying that Alabama "is doing badly in applying godly ethics" in areas of social welfare and taxation. It continues, "Those who look to Jesus for guidance might reflect on his preaching against hypocrisy and empty public displays of religion."

Pakistan Medical School Charged With Religious Discrimination

In Pakistan, a Christian student has filed suit in the Lahore High Court challenging the constitutionality of the admissions practices of King Edward Medical College. Today's Daily Times reports that the medical school offers additional points toward admission to Muslim students who have successfully memorized the Quran. The petitioner, Qandeel Sultan, argues that since she has merit certificates to prove her proficiency and knowledge of Christianity, she should also be given extra points toward admission. She argues that Article 25 of Pakistan's Constitution that provides "All citizens are equal before law and are entitled to equal protection of law", should be interpreted to require an equal education policy without discrimination on the basis of sex, religion, creed or caste. She has asked the court to prohibit the Admissions Board and Punjab government from commencing 2005-06 classes in medical colleges in Punjab until the final disposal of her petition.

December Church-State Guidance Offered Online To Public Officials

For government officials seeking guidance on the legal rules surrounding holiday displays and activities, at least two organizations have memos on their web sites offering their interpretations of the relevant precedents. Liberty Counsel's 7-page "Christmas Memo" covers publicly and privately sponsored religious holiday displays, religious holidays in public schools, and public school students in the context of religious holidays. The Anti-Defamation League has posted its "December Holiday Guidelines for Public Schools". Headlined "The December Dilemma", the web page discusses religion as an educational lesson, holiday assemblies and other public school activities, public school students performing religious music, and decorating public school classrooms and grounds with holiday symbols.

Idaho City's Homeless Shelter Lease Violates Establishment Clause

Last month's decision in Community House, Inc. v. City of Boise, 2005 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 29438 (D. Idaho, Oct. 28, 2005) has just become available. The Idaho federal district court issued a preliminary injunction prohibiting the city of Boise from continuing it arrangement with the Boise Rescue Mission (BRM) to lease and operate a homeless shelter if the BRM is requiring homeless residents of the shelter to attend religious services, or is requiring an explanation why the person cannot attend. The court held that even requiring an explanation for non-attendance "can easily amount to a subtle, and even not-so-subtle, form of coercion", which raises serious Establishment Clause issues.

Excerpts From High School Texts In California Litigation

A religious discrimination lawsuit against the University of California system brought by a group of Christian high schools is slated for trial on Dec. 12 in federal court in Los Angeles. The UC system has refused to recognize some high school courses using Christian-based texts as meeting minimum standards for applying students. (See prior posting.) Today's New York Times carries excerpts from textbooks used in the disputed courses. Here are three of them. The full article carries more:

On Thomas Jefferson, from United States History for Christian Schools, written by Timothy Keesee and Mark Sidwell (Bob Jones University, 2001): "American believers can appreciate Jefferson's rich contribution to the development of their nation, but they must beware of his view of Christ as a good teacher but not the incarnate son of God. As the Apostle John said, "Who is a liar but he that denieth that Jesus is the Christ? He is antichrist, that denieth the Father and the Son" (I John 2:22)".

On Mark Twain, from Elements of Literature for Christian Schools, by Ronald Horton, Donalynn Hess and Steven Skeggs (Bob Jones University, 2001): "Twain's outlook was both self-centered and ultimately hopeless. Denying that he was created in the image of God, Twain was able to rid himself of feeling any responsibility to his Creator. At the same time, however, he defiantly cut himself off from God's love. Twain's skepticism was clearly not the honest questioning of a seeker of truth but the deliberate defiance of a confessed rebel."

From Physics for Christian Schools, by R. Terrance Egolf and Linda Shumate (Bob Jones University, 2004): "You are about to embark on an adventure. The study of physics reveals the wonderful orderliness of God's creation - so orderly that it can be comprehended in terms of relatively simple principles (mathematical formulas). ... Physics is important because through it mankind learns how creation actually works. It satisfies our God-given curiosity about nature. Seeing that God does "great things and unsearchable; marvelous things without number" (Job 5:9), men have dedicated their lives to unraveling the rich mysteries of creation."

Boston "Holiday Tree" Provokes Objections

On Friday, Reuters reported on the furor in Boston when the city officially renamed a giant tree erected in a city park a "holiday tree" instead of a "Christmas tree." Evangelist Jerry Falwell complained that "there's been a concerted effort to steal Christmas". Boston Mayor Thomas Menino said he would keep calling the Nova Scotia spruce a "Christmas tree" regardless of what it said on the city's official Web site.

UPDATE: The Christian Post on Nov. 27 reports that after being threatened by Liberty Counsel with a law suit over changing the name of its tree, Boston Parks Commissioner Toni Pollak told the Boston Herald, "This is a Christmas tree. It's definitely a Christmas tree."

Mother Jones On Church-State

The December 2005 issue of Mother Jones magazine focuses on the interplay of conservative Christianity and the U.S. government. The issue, titled God and Country: Where the Christian Right Is Leading Us, has caused a stir among blogs of various political persuasions. Joseph Knippenberg at No Left Turns discusses it and promises more comment on his blog in the coming days. Talk To Action promises to host a national e-conference next week with Mother Jones on the issues raised by articles in the special issue.

Bankruptcy Disclosure Statement Filed By Archdiocese

The Federal Bankruptcy Code, 11 USC Sec. 1125, requires that in a bankruptcy reorganization, the debtor file a disclosure statement that is sent out to creditors who are asked to approve the reorganization plan. November 15 saw one of the most interesting ever disclosure statements filed. The Archdiocese of Portland filed its statement that, if approved by the court, will go out to creditors, including sex-abuse claimants. According to today's Catholic Sentinel, the disclosure statement says that the reorganization plan is designed to "fairly, justly, and equitably compensate valid Claimants . . . while allowing the archdiocese to continue its religious ministries, serve the spiritual needs of the faithful, and pursue its non-profit, charitable mission of service to those in need."

Currently the Archdiocese is arguing over which parish and school properties are available to creditors. (See related prior posting about Spokane case.) The disclosure statement says that if the archdiocese prevails, the compensation will be only about half as much as under last week's proposal-- shrinking from $40.5 million to $21.5 million. In the statement, the archdiocese said engaging the property dispute is in no one's best interest, since the case could take years.

The disclosure statement argues the Archdiocese side of the case: "All church property, whether held in the name of the archdiocese, the archbishop, a parish or a school, has been acquired with charitable donations made by parishioners, religious organizations, charitable foundations, and others. As such, the archdiocese asserts that much of the property titled in its name is held in trust, or is otherwise restricted, for the use of the benefit of the parishes, parishioners, parents, students and others who rely on the continued use of such property in order to practice their religion and educate their children, and that certain property is specifically designated for a particular purpose and can only be used for that purpose."

Missouri Stem Cell Initiative and Catholic Opposition

In Missouri, the Coalition for Lifesaving Cures headed by former U.S. Senator John Danfoth is promoting the Missouri Stem Cell Research and Cures Initiative. The group is circulating a petition to get an amendment to the state constitution on the ballot that would protect stem cell research in the state. Yesterday's St. Louis Post-Dispatch reported that on Sunday at all Catholic churches around St. Louis, parishioners will hear a homily telling them not to sign the petition. The bishops of the four diocese in the Catholic province of St. Louis have directed their parish priests to convey the church's position on embryonic stem cell research and its opposition to the petition initiative from their pulpits this week.

Islam and Freedom of Religion In Malaysia

A November 16 report from Foreign Policy In Focus, Islam, the State and Freedom of Religion In Malaysia, analyzes the success of Malaysia in promoting progressive Islam. It has successfully achieved economic growth while identifying itself with modern and liberal forms of religious expression. The government is promoting "Islam Hadhari", an approach that views Islam as evolving. The report analyzes the attacks on the present system and the issues of freedom of religion currently being faced by civil courts in Malaysia.

Faith-Based Prison Programs Grow In Popularity

Faith-based programs are becoming a more important part of the activities in jails and prisons around the country. Yesterday's newspapers carried reports on two of them. In Boulder, Colorado, more than 400 inmates at the Boulder County Jail regularly attend faith groups offered throughout the week. An Associated Press story reports that the programs serve nearly 1,000 inmates every year. 75 volunteers run more than 30 religious programs a month, serving not just Christians, but also Jews, Muslims and Buddhists.

The Tallahassee Democrat reports on the conversion of Florida's Wakulla Correctional Institution to a faith-based facility. The official designation means inmates must agree to attend religious or non-religious character-building classes and stay out of trouble. If they do not, they will be transferred to other less desirable prisons in the system. There are 3,000 inmates throughout the state on a waiting list for faith-based programs. The classes at Wakulla will be taught by volunteers in order to reduce the likelihood of church-state lawsuits. Wakulla, with its 1662 inmates, is the third prison in Florida to be designated faith-based and is the largest faith-based prison in the U.S.

Alliance Defense Fund Featured

The AP yesterday in an article carried by the Washington Post and other papers reviews the activities of the Alliance Defense Fund. The organization, headquartered in Scottsdale, Arizona, has grown since its founding in 1993 to more than 100 employees with branch offices in six states. It files an average of one lawsuit a week in cases involving Christianity and schools, gay marriage and other concerns of social conservatives. It claims it has won 75% of the suits it has filed.

Historical Thanksgiving Proclamations

The Washington Examiner today published excerpts from the Thanksgiving Proclamations issued by George Washington in 1789 and Abraham Lincoln in 1863. Washington urged citizens to:

unite in rendering unto him our sincere and humble thanks, for his kind care and protection of the People of this country previous to their becoming a Nation, for the signal and manifold mercies, and the favorable interpositions of his providence, which we experienced in the course and conclusion of the late war, for the great degree of tranquility, union, and plenty, which we have since enjoyed, for the peaceable and rational manner in which we have been enabled to establish constitutions of government for our safety and happiness, and particularly the national One now lately instituted, for the civil and religious liberty with which we are blessed, and the means we have of acquiring and diffusing useful knowledge and in general for all the great and various favors which he hath been pleased to confer upon us.

Lincoln's proclamation took a more somber tone:

And I recommend to them that while offering up the ascriptions justly due to Him for such singular deliverances and blessings, they do also, with humble penitence for our national perverseness and disobedience, commend to his tender care all those who have become widows, orphans, mourners or sufferers in the lamentable civil strife in which we are unavoidably engaged, and fervently implore the interposition of the Almighty Hand to heal the wounds of the nation and to restore it as soon as may be consistent with the Divine purposes to the full enjoyment of peace, harmony, tranquility and Union.

UPDATE: The full text of all Presidential Thanksgiving Proclamations are posted at Pilgrim Hall Museum. Thanks to Joseph M. Knippenberg for this lead, and see his discussion of Thanksgiving Procalmations here and here.

Chabad Seeking To Display Menorahs On Public Property

In the Boston area, difficult negotiations are taking place between town officials and Chabad rabbis over the display of menorahs on public property this Hanukkah season. While many Jewish organizations oppose on Establishment Clause grounds any kind of governmental display of religious symbols, Chabad-Lubavitch has often taken a different position. In 1989, in County of Allegheny v. ACLU, the U.S. Supreme Court held that a menorah is a religious symbol, but its display as part of a larger holiday tableau can be permissible as a "secular celebration of Christmas coupled with an acknowledgment of Chanukah as a contemporaneous alternative tradition".

Yesterday's Boston Jewish Advocate reports that Shrewsbury town selectmen originally refused a Chabad request to place a menorah in the town common. At a Nov. 21 meeting, they decided to retract their refusal, but have not given Chabad permission to display the menorah. In Wellesley, Rabbi Moshe Bleich successfully negotiated the display of a menorah on the town lawn in exchange for an agreement that he would rescind his request to hold a public ceremony. The Chabad rabbis involved argue that displaying a menorah is an important contributor to Jewish pride. Rabbi Michoel Green said, "Lots of Jewish kids here go to public schools and the Jewish kids are out of the loop."

Two New Religious Land Use Cases

In Friends of First United Methodist Church v. City of Seattle, (Nov. 21, 2005), a Washington state Court of Appeals rejected efforts of "Friends", a group that was attempting to prevent First United Methodist Church from demolishing its sanctuary and erecting an office tower and new adjoining sanctuary in its place. Friends claimed the downtown church sanctuary was historic and that under the State Environmental Policy Act, the church should have considered alternatives that did not involve its destruction. However, the court held that Seattle cannot burden the church's right to free exercise by preventing it from demolishing its sanctuary for landmark preservation purposes. Because landmark preservation is not a compelling interest, it cannot be used to justify action that has a coercive effect on the church's practice of religion. Since that is the case, the city cannot use requirements for an environmental impact statement to force the church to consider alternatives that cannot be enforced against it.

The Newtown, Conn. Bee reported yesterday on a Nov. 18 decision by the Danbury, Conn. Superior Court rejecting a Buddhist Temple's challenge to a 2003 Planning & Zoning Commission decision. The Cambodian Buddhist Society of Connecticut had sought to develop 10 acres of property it owns in a residential area with a temple and meeting hall. P&Z members in had unanimously rejected the proposal because it would increased traffic and noise, and would be "far too intense for this particular site." The Buddhist Society appealed the rejection, alleging that it violated the federal Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act and Connecticut's Religious Freedom Restoration Act. However the court disagreed, finding that: "The society's claim alleging a violation of the equal protection clause is unavailing because the court finds no evidence of selective treatment. The court further finds the society has neither established a 'substantial burden' nor a 'burden' on religious exercise sufficient to meet its prerequisite burden for a [religious freedom] claim...." UPDATE: The opinion is Cambodian Buddhist Society of CT, Inc. v. Newtown Planning & Zoning Commn., 2005 Conn. Super. LEXIS 3158 (Nov. 18, 2005).