Recent Prisoner Free Excercise Cases

In Sylvester v. Cain, (5th Cir., Feb. 20, 2009), the U.S. 5th Circuit Court of Appeals rejected plaintiff's claim that he was he was retaliated against on the basis of his religion when he filed a grievance. It also refused to consider a RLUIPA claim that had not been raised below.

In Barhite v. Caruso, 2009 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 13609 (WD MI, Feb. 23, 2009), a Michigan federal district court held that plaintiff inmate had not shown that his religious exercise was burdened when prison authorities removed pictures of young women from his possession. He claimed that they were taken because he was a Mormon after a Texas raid on and FLDS complex that led to removal of children.

In Jordan v. Caruso, 2008 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 98649 (WD MI, Dec. 8, 2008), a Michigan federal district court refused to dismiss free exercise claims brought by an African-American Jewish inmate who alleged that he was not excused from work on Saturdays and was not permitted to attend religious services by video conference equipment.

In Davis v. Hawaii, 2009 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 14004 (D HI, Feb. 23, 2009), an Hawaii federal magistrate judge granted defendants' motion to transfer to an Arizona federal district court a prisoner's claim that his rights were violated when Arizona prison officials prevented him from practicing his Native Hawaiian religion when they failed to hold a Makahiki closing ceremony feast.

In Corbeil v. Moore, 2009 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 14388 (WD LA, Jan. 30, 2009), a Louisiana federal magistrate judge dismissed an inmate's complaint that he was denied a kosher diet by prison authorities.

In Ahmed v. Willis, 2009 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 14245 (ED VA, Feb. 23, 2009), a Virginia federal district court dismissed plaintiff's claims under RLUIPA and the 1st Amendment challenging his removal from the Ramadan fasting list.

Indian State Proposes Controlling Board For Church Property

In the Indian state of Madhya Pradesh, the government is taking steps to form an agency to manage Catholic Church properties, including cemeteries, similar to the Muslim Wakf Board that manages Muslim religious properties. Calcutta's Telegraph reported Saturday that Church leaders plan to file suit in the Jabalpur High Court to prevent implementation of the plan. The state's Minorities Commission says the proposal is designed to increase transparency in management of Church properties.

Supreme Court Remands Companion Summum Case To 10th Circuit

As previously reported, last week the U.S. Supreme Court decided Pleasant Grove City v. Summum, holding that Pleasant Grove City, Utah need not acccept a "Seven Aphorisms" monument for a local park. In the 10th Circuit Court of Appeals below, there was a companion case decided at the same time, Summum v. Duchesne City, which involved a more complicated version of the same sort of underlying dispute. In that case, the only display already in the city's park was a 10 Commandments monument, and the city attempted to avoid Summum's request by transferring the land under the Ten Commandments display to a private party. (See prior posting.)

A petition for cert. had been filed in this companion case as well, but had never been acted upon by the Court. (See prior posting.) Today, in a brief order (Docket No. 07-690), the Court granted certiorari, vacated the judgment below and remanded the case for further consideration in light of the decision in the Pleasant Grove City case. Interestingly, the Court has also granted cert. this term in a case involving land transfers in order to avoid Establishment Clause concerns. (See prior posting.) However the "government speech" holding in the Pleasant Grove City case may be dispositive in the case remanded today, regardless of the Court's resolution on land transfers.

Cert. Denied In Ban on Coach Joining Team In Prayer

The U.S. Supreme Court today denied certiorari in Borden v. School District of East Brunswick, (Docket No. 08-482, March 2, 2009) (Order List.) In the case, the 3rd Circuit upheld the East Brunswick, New Jersey School District’s policy prohibiting faculty participation in student-initiated prayer. The lawsuit was filed by high school football coach Marcus Borden who wished join with his team in bowing his head during the team's pre-meal grace and kneeling during a team-led prayer in the locker-room. (See prior posting.)

State Education Officials Examine Tutor's Scientology-Related Techniques

Yesterday's Atlanta Journal Constitution reports that Georgia education officials, in conducting their annual inspection of a tutoring organization, Applied Scholastics, are looking carefully at its use of teaching techniques developed by Scientology founder L. Ron Hubbard. At issue is the question of whether Applied Scholsatic's program is secular, or instead is a disguised method of teaching Scientology. Georgia's state Department of Education approves and monitors tutors that are available for selection by parents of children who fail to meet federal academic standards. Tutors are paid with federal funds.

City's Construction Aid To Historic Church Is Questioned

In 2005, Carson City, Nevada city officials refused to grant First Presbyterian Church a permit to tear down its historic building and construct a new one. The old building, located in an historic district, had ties to Mark Twain who helped build it in the 1860's. However, the city did agree that it would aid the congregation fund the cost of a new building on an adjacent site. In 2006, the city gave the church $67,700 for design costs, and last month supervisors voted the church another $78,800 for sidewalks, landscaping and roof repairs. Now, according to yesterday's Los Angeles Times, Americans United says the funding raises a church-state issue, and threatens to file suit if the Board of Supervisors does not rescind last month's vote.

UPDATE: The Los Angeles Times reported on April 6 that Americans United has decided not to sue at this time because of the reluctance by courts to force religious institutions to return funds already awarded. However AU says it will sue if the city decides to make any more payments in the future.

Malaysia Will Permit Christian Publications To Use Term "Allah"

In Malaysia, the government's Home Ministry has issued an order under the internal Security Act declaring that the use of the word "Allah" in Christian publications is no longer prohibited. The Sun reported last week however that the Feb. 16 order requires any Christian publication using the term to carry in large type on the front cover the statement: "FOR CHRISTIANITY." The newspaper Catholic Herald has been in a dispute for some time with government officials over the paper's use of the term. (See prior posting.) The paper is studying the implications of the new order. (The Star 2/27.)

Recent Articles and Book Of Interest

From SSRN:

• Miranda Perry Fleischer, Theorizing the Charitable Tax Subsidies: The Role of Distributive Justice, (U Illinois Law & Economics Research Paper No. LE09-006, Feb.24, 2009).


• Jeanne L. Schroeder, Totem, Taboo and the Concept of Law: Myth in Hart and Freud, (Cardozo Legal Studies Research Paper No. 253, Feb. 24, 2009).


• Ajay K. Mehrotra, "Render Unto Caesar . . .": Religion/Ethics, Expertise, and the Historical Underpinnings of the Modern American Tax System, (Loyola University Chicago Law Journal, Vol. 40, 2009).

From SmartCILP:

• Raymond B. Marcin, God's Littlest Children and the Right to Live: The Case for a Positivist Pro-Life Overturning of Roe, 25 Journal of Contemporary Health Law & Policy 38-75 (2008).

New Book:

• Lisa A. Runquist & Jeannie Carmedelle Frey, Guide to Representing Religious Organizations, (ABA, Feb. 2009).

California Muslims Distressed After Disclosure of FBI Infiltration of Mosques

Today's Los Angeles Times reports that local Muslims are dismayed after revelations last week that during 2006 and 2007 the FBI used an informant to attend several Orange County (CA)mosques to gather evidence against Afghanistan-born Ahmadullah Sais Niazi who authorities say had ties to Al Qaeda. Since the disclosures, some Muslims are avoiding mosques and praying at home. Others are reducing their contributions to mosques to avoid attracting attention, or donating in cash to avoid creating records. Some mosques are asking speakers to avoid issues like U.S. foreign policy in their sermons.

Episcopal Diocese Sues To Gain Title To Property of Dissident Philadelphia Parish

Last week, according to Virtue Online, the Episcopal Diocese of Pennsylvania filed suit in a Pennsylvania state court seeking to recover the property and assets of Philadelphia's Rosemont Church of the Good Shepherd. While the parish has not formally dissociated itself from the Episcopal Church, the complaint (full text) in Protestant Episcopal Church of the Diocese of Pennsylvania v. Church of the Good Shepard Rosemont, Pennsylvania, (Com Pl, filed 2/19/2009), alleges that those in control of Good Shepard no longer consider the parish to be a constituent part of the Diocese of Pennsylvania or the Episcopal Church. It says that the parish has ceased to act in accord with the Constitution and Canons of the Episcopal Church. In 2002, Bishop Charles Bennison inhibited and "deposed" the parish's leader, Rev. David Moyer, who has been ordained as Bishop by the more conservative Traditional Anglican Union. Last year, a state trial court rejected Moyer's suit that claimed the diocese engaged in fraud when it asserted that Moyer had "abandoned the communion of the Episcopal Church." (See prior posting.)

Catholic Cardinal May Be Appointed To House of Lords for First Time In 500 Years

AP reported yesterday that for the first time in nearly 500 years, a Catholic Archbishop may be appointed to Britain's House of Lords. Prime Minister Gordon Brown raised speculation on the possibility in response to a reporter's question ofnwhether Cardinal Archbishop Cormac Murphy-O'Connor who is retiring later this year is in line for a seat. Brown responded: "These are things to be discussed at a later stage." There are 26 bishops from the Church of England in the House of Lords, and retired chief rabbis have been appointed.However relations with the Catholic Church have been an issue since the 16th century when King Henry VIII broke with the Vatican over its refusal to grant him an annulment.

Questions Continue On Improper Proselytizing In Military

Today's New York Times reports that questions persist on whether the military continues to be involved in improper religious proselytizing. An official military suicide-prevention video shows former Pittsburgh Steelers quarterback Terry Bradshaw talking about how Christian prayer helped him through bouts of depression. The Pentagon says it has received 50 complaints of religious discrimination from all branches of the military from 2005 to 2007. In another incident, a former Air Force Reserve fighter pilot says he received a negative certification and ultimately lost his flying certification after writing a letter complaining about Christian prayers at homecoming ceremonies for service personnel returning from Iraq and Afghanistan. A lawsuit challenging improper promotion of religion in the military is pending in federal court. (See prior posting.)

Meanwhile, the Obama administration may be more sympathetic to complaints about church-state breaches in the military than was the Bush Pentagon. Last week for the first time, a member of the Joint Chiefs of Staff met with activist Mikey Weinstein, head of the Military Religious Freedom Foundation. Air Force chief of staff, Gen. Norton A. Schwartz, acknowledged to Weinstein that there is a problem. But retired General Bruce L. Fister, executive director of the Officers’ Christian Fellowship, said: "the problem is that Christians are going to operate one way or the other, and whenever the church has been persecuted, it’s grown stronger."

Nebraska Appeals Court Dismisses Suit Against God

AP yesterday reported that the Nebraska Court of Appeals has dismissed a lawsuit filed by former state Senator Ernie Chambers against God, seeking an injunction to stop His causing, death destruction and terror through various natural disasters. Last October, a Douglas County (NE) trial judge dismissed to suit because God had not been served with process. (See prior posting.) Chambers appealed arguing that since God is all-knowing, defendant has notice of the lawsuit. Now the Court of Appeals has vacated the judgment saying that courts will not decide abstract questions or hypothetical or fictitious issues.

Likely Nominee To Head EEOC Is Disclosed

The Washington Post reported Saturday that Cassandra Butts is likely to be President Obama's nominee to chair the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission. Butts, a former Harvard Law School classmate of Obama's, is currently deputy White House counsel. Formerly she had positions with NAACP Legal Defense Fund, was on House minority leader Richard Gephardt's staff and was a senior vice president for domestic policy at the Center for American Progress. The EEOC enforces federal employment discrimination laws, including laws banning religious discrimination in employment.

Vatican Says Statement By Holocaust Denying Bishop Is Insufficient Apology

On Thursday, Zenit published an apology of sorts from Lefebvrite Bishop Richard Williamson in connection with his comments denying the Holocaust. Earlier this month, Pope Benedict XVI lifted Williamson's long-standing excommunication, along with that of 3 other right-wing bishops. (See prior posting.) However, following protests, the Pope told Williamson that he must recant his Holocaust views to be fully reinstated. (See prior posting.) According to the New York Times on Friday, Williamson's recent apology is not seen by the Vatican as sufficient to restore him to full communion with the Church. Apparently in recent weeks, Williamson has contacted another Holocaust denier, David Irving, for assistance in assessing the Holocaust. Irving served 13 months in prison in Austria for "glorifying ... the German Nazi Party."

Local Sex-Offender Residence Restrictions Invalidated In Aftermath of Religious Issue

After losing a free exercise challenge to sex offender restrictions that prohibited him from living within walking distance of a synagogue in Rockland County, New York (see prior posting), Yoel Oberlander succeeded last month in invalidating on other grounds a local law that created "pedophile-free child safety zones" in the county. In People v. Oberlander, (Sup. Ct., Jan. 22, 2009), a New York state trial court held that the local ordinance is pre-empted by a less restrictive state law. The lawsuit was filed after the Probation Department rejected 15 different residence locations proposed by Oberlander.

U.S. Withdraws From Further Participation In Durban II Conference

The U.S. State Department announced Friday (press release) that the U.S. is withdrawing from further participation in the United Nations Durban Review Conference and will re-engage only if dramatic revisions are made in the document being drafted for the Conference. It said the current draft "has gone from bad to worse." The United States and Israel walked out of the first Conference, held in Durban in 2001, because of the anti-Semitic and anti-Israel focus of many participants. Now, after preliminarily participating in planning sessions for Durban II (see prior posting), the U.S. essentially joins Canada and Israel which have already announced they will boycott this year's Conference. The U.S. is concerned not just about the anti-Israel focus of the current Conference draft document, but also about its endorsement of a ban on "defamation of religion" and its language on reparations for slavery.

However, attempting to maintain a U.S. presence in United Nations human rights efforts, the State Department also said the U.S. would return as an observer at this month's session of the U.N. Human Rights Council, even though it is concerned about the trajectory of discussions there. Reporting on developments, the Washington Post points out that the Bush administration withdrew HRC observers last June.

HHS Will Propose Repeal of Recent Health Care Conscience Regulations

The Washington Post today reports that the Obama administration will issue for comment a proposal to rescind the conscience regulations covering health care workers adopted in the final days of the Bush administration. Those rules prohibit state and local governments, as well as health care institutions, that receive federal funds from discriminating against those who object to furnishing abortion, sterilization and various other services. (See prior posting.) A Department of Health and Human Services spokesman suggested that the Obama administration favors a narrower rule protecting conscience rights of those who object to abortion, but it opposes the recent regulations that cover a wide range of other services as well. A compromise could arise after comments are filed during the 30-day comment period that will be provided.

James Dobson Steps Down As Chairman of Focus on the Family

James Dobson has stepped down as chairman of Focus on the Family, the conservative Christian pro-family group he founded in 1977. According to CBN News today, the 72-year old Dobson wants to make way for new, younger leadership. Jim Daly, president and CEO of the organization will take over as chairman. Dobson will continue to host the organization's daily radio program and speak out on moral issues. The AP says Dobson's move is part of a succession plan begun 6 years ago. Reactions both by Dobson's friends and detractors were quick to come. Gary Bauer, president of American Values and chairman of the Campaign for Working Families, said of Dr. Dobson and his wife Shirley: "They have been warriors for faith, family and freedom, and I trust they will continue to fight the good fight for many more years to come."

Barry W. Lynn, executive director of Americans United for Separation of Church and State, issued a statement saying in part: "Focus on the Family is merely rearranging the deck chairs on its big, intolerant ship. I do not expect this change to mean we will see any moderation in the rhetoric of Focus on the Family or its arm in Washington, the Family Research Council. For years, FOF has been the leading voice of religious extremism and intolerance in America."

Nonprofits Oppose Obama Budget Plan Limiting Some Charitable Deductions

President Obama yesterday released his budget proposals in a 140-page document titled A New Era of Responsibility: Renewing America's Promise. One provision is controversial among non-profit groups, including a number of religious organizations. For families with incomes over $250,000, itemized tax deductions (including charitable deductions) would be at only a 28% tax rate instead of 35%. The additional revenues generated would help expand health insurance coverage. Today's New York Times says that "wealthy donors and the nonprofit groups they support were in an uproar" over the proposal. However it goes on to report that surveys indicate few wealthy donors are likely to reduce their giving as a result of the change and many high-income donors are already capped at 28% because of the alternative minimum tax. A statement opposing Obama's plan issued by United Jewish Communities however argues that "any reduction in the tax benefits available for charitable giving will have a significant negative impact on giving."