Religion Clause

Thursday, November 26, 2009

Obama Sends Greetings To Hajj Pilgrims As Eid-ul-Adha Approaches

As Muslim pilgrims from around the world, including 20,000 Americans, performed the Hajj, President Barack Obama yesterday issued greetings to them in anticipation of tomorrow's observance of Eid-ul-Adha. His statement read in part:

Michelle and I would like to send our best wishes to all those performing Hajj this year, and to Muslims in America and around the world who are celebrating Eid-ul-Adha. The rituals of Hajj and Eid-ul-Adha both serve as reminders of the shared Abrahamic roots of three of the world’s major religions.

During Hajj, the world’s largest and most diverse gathering, three million Muslims from all walks of life – including thousands of American Muslims – will stand in prayer on Mount Arafat. The following day, Muslims around the world will celebrate Eid-ul-Adha and distribute food to the less fortunate to commemorate Abraham’s willingness to sacrifice his son out of obedience to God.

His statement also pointed to U.S. Saudi Arabian cooperation in preventing the spread of the H1N1 virus during Hajj ceremonies. The President's statement was also made available in Arabic, Persian, Dari, Urdu, Pashto, Russian and French translations.

Wednesday, November 25, 2009

Brooklyn Neighbors Object To Loud Recorded Church Bells

In the Marine Park neighborhood of Brooklyn, New York, some residents are protesting the decibel level of church bells from St. Thomas Aquinas Church. Your Nabe reported yesterday that the problem began when the church began to use a speaker system to play recorded bell melodies from 9 a.m. to 7 p.m. each day. The city's Department of Environmental Protection says that the city's noise ordinance does not apply to organs, bells and chimes used by houses of worship. (New York City Administrative Code, Sec. 24-217). City Councilman Lew Fidler is trying to mediate the situation, but so far has been unsuccessful. Neighborhood resident Joseph Zelinsky says that the exemption for church bells should not apply here because the noise is caused by loud speakers, not bells.

Court Rejects Attempt To Block Demolition of Catholic Church Building

A state trial court in Galveston, Texas on Tuesday dismissed a lawsuit that had been brought by parishioners of Our Mother of Mercy Church to prevent the Catholic Archdiocese of Galveston-Houston from demolishing the church building. Yesterday's Houston Chronicle reports that while the church building survived Hurricane Ike last year, the Archdiocese decided to close the church as part of a plan to consolidate parishes. (Letter from Archdiocese.) Galveston County district judge John Elisor held that the lawsuit was asking the court to improperly interfere with internal church affairs.

Town Decides To Remove Creche Rather Than Permit Atheist and Other Messages

The Chambersburg, Pennsylvania Borough Council on Monday voted to allow only American flags and flowers on the town's Memorial Square fountain war memorial. The decision means that the Nativity scene that was placed on the Square again this year by the Chambersburg Garden Club must now be taken down. Council's action came after an atheist group sought permission to put up a sign on the Square showing a rising sun over the words "Celebrating Solstice. Honoring Atheist War Veterans." Yesterday's Chambersburg Public Opinion says Council members concluded they would rather have no displays on Memorial Square than permit an influx of competing messages each holiday season. Carl Silverman, director of the mid-state chapter of PA Nonbelievers, said Council's decision reflected discrimination against atheists and other nonbelievers. [Thanks to Scott Mange for the lead.]

UPDATE: The Dec. 4 Harrisburg Patriot-News reports that the Nativity scene has found a new home in front of Central Presbyterian Church, just across the street from the Memorial Square Fountain.

India's Parliament Disturbed Over Commission Report on 1992 Mosque Destruction

According to Time Magazine yesterday, a report delivered in June to India's Prime Minister, and leaked to the press last week, on a 1992 incident in Ayodhya, in the northern state of Uttar Pradesh, has created so much turmoil that both houses of Parliament have had to be adjouned repeatedly over the last two days. At issue is the report by the Liberhan Commission of Enquiry on the 1992 destruction of the Babri Mosque by Hindu extremists who believe the mosque was built on the birthplace of the Hindu god Ram. Politicians had exploited passions by promising to build a Temple to Ram on the site. BJP leaders have always claimed that the attack on the mosque was spontaneous. The new report, however, concludes that the attack was meticulously planned, and approved by senior members of the Hindu nationalist Bhartiya Janata Party (BJP).

3rd Circuit OK's Ban On Religious Holiday Songs At School Concerts

In Stratechuk v. Board of Education, South Orange-Maplewood School District, (3d Cir., Nov. 24, 2009), the U.S. 3rd Circuit Court of Appeals upheld a New Jersey school district's policy banning celebratory religious holiday music at school-sponsored holiday concerts. Holiday music could still be taught in music classes. Also, songs with religious content not specifically related to the holidays at hand could be performed in concerts. The 3d Circuit rejected plaintiff's argument under the Establishment Clause that the policy's purpose and effect is to disapprove of religion. The school argued that its purpose was to prevent governmental endorsement of religious holidays. The Court concluded:

Certainly, those of us who were educated in the public schools remember holiday celebrations replete with Christmas carols, and possibly even Chanukah songs, to which no objection had been raised. Since then, the governing principles have been examined and defined with more particularity. Many decisions about how to best create an inclusive environment in public schools, such as those at issue here, are left to the sound discretion of the school authorities.

The court also rejected plaintiff's claim that the school was unconstitutionally restricting students' access to ideas. Yesterday's Newark Star-Ledger reported on the decision. (See prior related posting.)

Lawsuit Challenges Museum's Cancellation of Pro-Intelligent Design Film

A press release yesterday from the American Freedom Alliance (AFA) reports on a lawsuit it has filed against the California Science Center (CSC). AFA says its free expression rights were infringed when CSC, a state agency, cancelled a scheduled showing in its IMAX Theater of "We Are Born of the Stars"-- a documentary promoting Intelligent Design. The lawsuit alleges that CSC cancelled the film because it did not want the museum to be viewed as legitimizing Intelligent Design as a scientific theory. The complaint alleges that CSC's President, Jeffrey Rudolph, was pressured to cancel the event by colleagues at the Smithsonian Institution, the University of Southern California, the Huntington Library and elsewhere. Yesterday was the 150th anniversary of the publication of Darwin's Origin of the Species, and AFA had planned two films to kick off a series of events exploring competing theories on life's origins.

UPDATE: Here is the full text of the complaint in American Freedom Alliance v. California Science Center, (Cal. Super. Ct., filed 11/19/2009). [Thanks to Willaim Becker.]

Tuesday, November 24, 2009

White House State Dinner Accommodates Hindu Vegetarianism

Tonight the White House is hosting the first State Dinner of the Obama Presidency, honoring India's prime minister, Dr. Manmohan Singh. (White House Blog.) The carefully created dinner menu takes account of the vegetarian diet practiced by many Hindus. All the courses are vegetarian, except that guests have the option of Green Curry Prawns instead of Roasted Potato Dumplings for the main course. Blog of the Times is covering various aspects of the dinner.

Suit Challenges School's Censorship of Anti-Islam T-Shirts

Yesterday the ACLU of Florida filed a federal lawsuit against the Alachua County (FL) school board challenging the constitutionality of the district's policy of banning students from wearing T-shirts with messages that are "offensive to others." The Gainesville Sun reports that the suit, alleging freedom of expression claims, was filed on behalf of two families that are members of the Dove World Outreach Center. School officials asked the students involved to cover their T-shirts which, on the back, read "Islam is of the Devil." On the front, the T-shirts read: "I stand in truth with Dove World Outreach Center", followed by, "Jesus answered I am the way and the truth and the life; no one goes to the Father except through me."

Some students were told they could not wear the T-shirts at all. Others were only required to cover the message on the back, but not the Christian message on the front. The ACLU says the issue is whether, under the First Amendment, school officials can permit positive messages about faith, religion or other matters, while banning negative messages about those subjects. School officials say they can bar messages that are disruptive to the learning environment, substantially interfere with maintaining discipline at school, or which infringe other students' rights.

Estate of Deceased FLDS Leader Seeks Return of UEP Trust

The complicated and long-running efforts of a Utah state court to reform the $120 million FLDS United Effort Plan Trust (see prior posting) has run into a new complication. AP reported yesterday that attorneys for the estate of Rulon Jeffs-- former leader of the polygamous FLDS Church-- have filed a motion asking the court to return control of the trust to the estate. The court took control of the trust in 2005 after Warren Jeffs, Rulon's son, was charged with mismanaging the property held by the trust. The new motion argues that the property belongs to the Corporation of the President of the FLDS Church, and that the court's prior actions have denied the estate, and the Corporation of the President, due process.

Iran's Largest Paper Shut Down For Publishing Photo of Baha'i Temple

AFP reported yesterday that Iran's Press Supervisory Board has ordered Hamshahri, the country's largest circulation newspaper, closed down because it published a photo on its front page of a Baha'i temple. The photo was part of an ad encouraging tourists to visit the Baha'i shrine. Iran's 300,000 Baha'is have been discriminated against over the years, and the religion is not recognized as a minority religion by Iran. (Background.) However, according to an AP report, Hamshahri, run by the municipality of Tehran, has also been critical of President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad. Tehran's mayor, Mohammad Baqer Qalibaf, is a critic and rival of Ahmadinejad. Over 120 pro-reform newspapers have been ordered closed since 2000.

UPDATE: An Iranian news agency says that courts have lifted the ban on Hamshahri one day after it was imposed. (Fresno Bee, 11/24.)

State Department Official Testifies On Religious Freedom In Middle East

On Nov. 19, a subcommittee of the House Committee on Foreign Affairs held a hearing on The State of Political and Religious Freedom in the Middle East. Michael H. Posner, Assistant Secretary, Bureau of Democracy, Human Rights, and Labor, testified. (Full text of Posner's statement.) He said in part:

We recognize that there are many significant challenges to religious freedom and tolerance in the Middle East and South Asia. Throughout the region religious minorities do not enjoy equal access to education, employment, healthcare, and legal recourse. In some places, blasphemy and apostasy laws inhibit the social contributions of minorities and exacerbate inter-religious tension. In many Muslim-majority countries, minority Muslim sects are marginalized and members of the majority sect are not free to challenge official religious opinions. I want to emphasize that religious freedom is not just a concern for religious minorities; majority communities need space to self-critique and adapt to changing conditions over time.

Reporting on the hearing, the Pakistan Christian Post yesterday said that questions asked of Posner during the hearing demonstrated that the U.S. has not seriously pressured its allies Saudi Arabia and Egypt to comply with international human rights law.

Hannah Rosenthal To Be Named State Department's Special Envoy On Anti-Semitism

JTA reported yesterday that President Obama will name Hannah Rosenthal as the State Department's new Special Envoy to Combat and Monitor Anti-Semitism. Rosenthal served from 2000 to 2005 as executive director of the Jewish Council for Public Affairs. Her appointment was welcomed by the ADL and the JCPA. However, according to JTA, some conservatives criticize her, citing her service on the advisory board of J Street, a new organization that describes itself as the political arm of the pro-Israel, pro-peace movement.

Iraq Gives Added Payment To Mixed Sunni-Shiite Couples Marrying

In Iraq, the country's vice-president, Tariq al-Hashemi, is trying to heal rifts between Shiites and Sunnis by encouraging intermarriage between the two groups. Monday's USA Today says that Hashemi is offering a government gift of $2000 to each mixed couple that marries. About a dozen of these couples will take part in a eremony and celebration on Friday, funded by the government. The mixed couples will receive their $2000 along with government funded wedding clothes and hotel rooms. Some 375 couples from the same sect will also marry in the subsidized group ceremony. They will receive a $750 gift from the government.

Monday, November 23, 2009

FBI Releases 2008 U.S. Hate Crimes Data

The FBI today released its report on Hate Crime Statistics 2008. The FBI says the numbers are up slightly from last year, but the number of agencies reporting data varies from year to year. Of the 9,168 hate crime offenses (in 7,783 incidents), 1,606 were motivated by religious bias. (Incidents and Offenses data.) The largest percentage of those (65.7%) were anti-Jewish. 7.7% were anti-Islamic, 4.7% were anti-Catholic, 3.7% were anti-Protestant, 0.9% were anti Atheist/ Agnostic. Some 3,608 hate crime offenses were against property. 6.6% of those were directed at religious organizations. [Thanks to Michael Lieberman for the lead.]

UPDATE: The ADL on Monday issued a press release reacting to the new data and calling for "a coordinated campaign to prevent, deter, and respond effectively to criminal violence motivated by bigotry and prejudice." The ADL has also compiled charts giving additional data: (1) 10 year comparison of number of hate crimes; (2) number of law enforcement agencies reporting, by state; (3) hate crimes data since 1992 from 50 largest cities; and (4) state-by-state incident reports 1991-2008.

Suit Challenges Policy of Opening College Events With Prayer

Americans United announced Friday that it has filed a federal lawsuit against California's South Orange County Community College District challenging the practice at Saddleback College in Mission Viejo of opening various sorts of official events-- some of them mandatory for students-- with prayers. The complaint (full text) in Westphal v. Wagner, (CD CA, filed Nov. 19, 2009), alleges:

3. For years, the trustees, the chancellor, and the president of Saddleback College have routinely held official prayer at numerous events for college students and faculty, including scholarship ceremonies, graduations, and the Chancellor’s Opening Sessions.

4. The college communities are religiously diverse, and the official prayers deeply offend many students, faculty, and staff. For some, the official prayers are insulting to their deeply held religious beliefs, or even offensive to God. For some, the official prayers make them feel like outsiders because they do not belong to the District’s preferred faith community. And for some, the official prayers represent the District’s attempt to impose that preferred faith on them.

5. For years, therefore, college students, faculty, and staff, as well as scholarship donors, community members, and others have publicly objected to the District’s prayer practice, requesting that a moment of silence or some other, less divisive practice be adopted instead. But rather than respecting the beliefs of its faculty and students, the trustees, the chancellor, and Saddleback College’s president have responded by expanding the prayer practice, by making the prayers ever more religious and divisive, and by publicly attacking members of minority faiths and nonbelievers for not sharing the District’s preferred faith. Plaintiffs therefore have no choice but to seek provisional relief and a permanent injunction to stop the prayer.

[Thanks to Alliance Alert for the lead.]

White House Marks Sikh Holiday For First Time

On Friday, Nov. 13 [corrected], the White House hosted a reception commemorating the 540th anniversary of the birth of Guru Nanak Dev Ji, the first guru in Sikhism. According to the White House Blog, this is the first time this holiday has ever been celebrated at the White House. Sikh leaders from around the country joined a number of White House staff at the reception that featured traditional hymns led by the Sikh Kirtani Chanters from the Golden Temple in Amritsar, India.

Norwegian Univeristy Debates Use of Gym For Muslim Prayers

At Norway's University of Oslo, Muslim students are encountering resistance to their request to use a university gymnasium for a half hour each Friday for prayer services. Europe News reported last week that the deans of Law and Theology want a debate on how to accommodate religious needs of students while protecting the University's common, secular space. Muslim students currently have a prayer room at the University, but it is too small to accommodate the 40 to 80 students who attend on Fridays.

Recent Prisoner Free Excercise Cases

In Perez v. Westchester County Department of Corrections, (2d Cir., Nov. 19, 2009), the U.S. 2nd Circuit Court of Appeals held that plaintiffs who obtained a settlement requiring prison authorities to serve Muslim prisoners halal meat were "prevailing parties" for purposes of the award of attorneys' fees and that the fee caps in the Prison Litigation Reform Act apply even though some of the plaintiffs were released before the successful resolution of the litigation.

In Pressley v. Madison, 2009 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 107231 (ND GA, Nov. 17, 2009), a Georgia federal district judge permitted a Muslim plaintiff to move ahead with her complaint that she was not permitted to wear her hijab covering her head while temporarily transferred for two days from prison to a county jail. The suit asks for an injunction to prohibit Barrow County Jail from depriving Muslim women of their hijabs and also seeks several million dollars in damages.

In Williams v. Cate, 2009 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 107920 (ED CA, Nov. 10, 2009), a California federal magistrate judge allowed a prisoner who was a member of the House of Yahweh faith to proceed against some of the defendants named in his lawsuit for alleged violations of the free exercise and equal protection clauses, as well as RLUIPA. The lawsuit alleged refusals to accommodate plaintiff's religious dietary requirements, failure to hold House of Yahweh religious services and discrimination in funding from the religious services budget.

In Morris v. Woodford, 2009 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 107612 (ND CA, Nov. 18, 2009), a California federal district court held that a prisoner had stated a cognizable claim under the 1st Amendment and RLUIPA. His complaint alleged denial and confiscation of his Qu'ran and other Islamic study and prayer materials.

In Lynch v. Huffman, 2009 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 107476 (SD IN, Nov. 17, 2009), an Indiana federal district court dismissed an inmate's claim that his free exercise rights were violated when his request to see a chaplain was ignored while he was in administrative segregation for two months. He did not allege this imposed a substantial burden on his religious exercise. Moreover the claim was now moot.