Court Says Minister's Breach of Contract Claim Might Be Able To Proceed

In Mundie v. Christ United Church of Christ, (PA Super, Dec. 31, 2009), a Pennsylvania appellate court refused to dismiss at this stage of the litigation a breach of contract lawsuit by a pastor who had been terminated by his congregation's Consistory. The trial court, accepting defendant's First Amendment argument, had held it lacked jurisdiction because the dispute was ecclesiastical in nature. The appellate court, however, held that plaintiff should first be given an opportunity to show that he can prove his case without resort to evidence that would excessively entangle the court with church matters.

Businessman Creates Protest To Swiss Ban on Minarets

Today's Wall Street Journal reports on the attention being given to a protest mounted by a Swiss businessman who strongly disagrees with the result of November's Swiss referendum banning any new construction of minarets. (See prior posting.) In Bussigny, Switzerland, businessman Guillaume Morand quickly constructed an illuminated 20-foot high plastic and wood minaret, attached to the chimney of his shoe store warehouse. Morand said: "The referendum was a scandal. I was ashamed to be Swiss. I don't have the power to do much, but I wanted to give a message of peace to Muslims." The Justice Ministry does not plan to take action against Morand. It says it regards the minaret as a temporary structure. Neither does the town's acting mayor who says this is not really a minaret since it has no connection to a mosque.

Report Details Crimes Against U.S. Christian Churches In 2009

Christian Post reported yesterday that a new report for 2009 on "Crimes Against Christian Organizations in the United States" indicates that there were at least 1,237 crimes committed against Christian churches and ministries in the United States last year. The report issued by the Christian Security Network says that over 700 of the incidents were burglaries.

Orthodox Church In Russia Poised For More Political Involvement

Yesterday's Georgian Daily says that Russian Orthodox Patriarch Kirrill is positioning the Russian Orthodox Church for a greater role in Russian politics. The paper first cites a speech by Kirrill to the Russian Academy of State Service in which he argued that Russia should be judged by its unique values and not by "alien" European criteria-- a position that echos the views of Prime Minister Vladimir Putin. Second, he has strongly criticized Europeans for surrendering their values to "passionate" Muslims. Finally Kirrill signed a new cooperation agreement with the Russian Academy of State Service, pressing the government to aid religious groups according to their relative size. The agreement opens the way for more priests to receive training at the Academy of State Service.

Attorney Hit With Rule 11 Sanctions For Campaign To Recuse Catholic Judge

A Florida federal district court judge has imposed extensive Rule 11 sanctions on attorney Loring Spotler who turned motions to force the judge to recuse himself into a "dogged and relentless" campaign against the judge when the motions were denied. In a group of cases captioned Bettis v. Toys "R" Us, (SD FL, Sept. 30, 2009), Judge William J. Zloch recounted the beginnings of the controversy:

Two years ago, in Sabatier and Bettis, Mr. Spolter claimed that I was a Catholic zealot bent on ruling against women who returned to work after giving birth. He extrapolated as much from the facts that I am Catholic, some of the law clerks I have hired attended Catholic law schools, and I have affiliations with the Federalist Society. Based on these facts, he moved for my recusal from both cases.

A 2007 ABA Journal article explained that the charges grew out of Judge Zloch's ties to Ave Maria Law School and his hiring three law clerks from the school. However they escalated into charges that the Clerk's Office was engaged in a conspiracy to undercut the random assignment of cases to different judges. Judge Zloch concluded in his opinion:

In these collected cases there is no question that Mr. Spolter acted in bad faith, both objective and subjective, when he filed his Motions To Recuse. He filed these Motions knowing they had no basis in fact or law and he continued to defend them in the face of overwhelming evidence of their baselessness.... He did this for an improper purpose: to defame and cast a cloud over the Federal judiciary in relentless pursuit of recusal.

The court imposed $99,140 of defendants' attorneys fees and on Spotler, and fined Spotler an additional $10,000. In addition he suspended Spotler from practice before the federal court for 42 months and referred Spotler to the Florida bar. The ABA Journal yesterday reported on the decision.

South African President Takes 3rd Wife In Zulu Ceremony

South African President Jacob Zuma yesterday married his third wife in a traditional Zulu ceremony, according to the London Guardian. The Zulu tribe practices polygamy by tradition, and it is recognized under South African law. South Africa's Constitution (Sec.31) protects the cultural practices of Zulus and other groups. Zuma's new wife is Tobeka Madiba, described as a socialite from Durban. Zuma apparently has fathered three children with Madiba. The 67-year old Zuma is also planning to add yet another wife before long. Gloria Bongi Ngema, who now works for IBM in Johannesburg and who has a child by Zuma, presented umbondo (gifts) to the Zuma family last week, customarily a precursor to marriage. The Johannesburg Times yesterday reported that Christian Democratic Party leader Rev. Theunis Botha strongly criticized Zuma, saying that Zuma's "alarming return to ancestral worship is a giant step back into the dark ages."

Recent Articles and Book of Interest

From SmartCILP:

• Steven F. Friedell, Some Observations About Jewish Law in Israel's Supreme Court, 8 Washington University Global Studies Law Review 659-700 (2009).


• Jose Gabilondo, Institutional Pluralism from the Standpoint of Its Victims: Calling the Question on Indiscriminate (In)tolerance [Abstract], 21 Law & Literature 387-401 (2009).


• Michael P. Moreland, Universalism and Particularism in Bioethics: Lessons from Theological Ethics [Abstract], 21 Law & Literature 415-430 (2009).


• Johannes Reich, Switzerland: Freedom of Creed and Conscience, Immigration, and Public Schools in the Postsecular State--Compulsory Coeducational Swimming Instruction Revisited, 7 I.Con: International Journal of Constitutional Law 754-767 (2009).


• Nicholas Wolterstorff, Donald A. Giannella Memorial Lecture: Can Human Rights Survive Secularization?, 54 Villanova Law Review 411-420 (2009).


• Constitutional Law Symposium: Global Perspectives on Religion, the State, and Constitutionalism. Articles by Abdullahi Ahmed An-Na'im, Thomas F. Farr, Frank S. Ravitch, Richard W. Garnett, Laura Dudley Jenkins and T. Jeremy Gunn. 57 Drake Law Review 829-984 (2009).


• The Federalist Society Religious Freedom Panel. Religious Liberties: The International Religious Freedom Act. William L. Saunders, moderator; Thomas F. Farr, Richard W. Garnett, IV and T. Jeremy Gunn, panelists. 31 Houston Journal of International Law 469-514 (2009).

The Journal of Church & State, Vol 51, No. 2, Spring 2009 has recently been issued.

Recent Book:

• Jytte Klausen, The Cartoons that Shook the World, (Yale Univ. Press., Sept. 2009).

Virgina Muslim Prison Chaplains Want More State Support

Virginia is one of the few states that does not have its own staff of professional chaplains. Instead it contracts with the Chaplain Service of the Churches of Virginia, a Protestant group, to provide religious programs for inmates of all faiths. The chaplain group receives $780,000 per year from the prison commissary fund to help subsidize its activities. Today's Lynchburg (VA) News & Advance reports that the all-volunteer Muslim Chaplain Service, which for the first time was recently awarded a $25,000 grant from the state, wants more state funding so it can hire more imams to serve prisoners. The Protestant Chaplain Service agrees that more Muslim chaplains are needed to serve the 1,700 to 2,500 Muslims in Virginia prisons and to prevent radicalization through "jailhouse Islam."

Report Says Egypt Court Upholds Ban of Niqab In University Exam Rooms

Reuters and UAE's The National report that yesterday an administrative court in Cairo, Egypt upheld the decision by higher education minister Hany Helal and heads of three universities to bar women from wearing the niqab (full face veil) while taking university exams. The government said that the ban was imposed in part because students (male and female) were taking exams disguised as others by wearing the face veil. Some three weeks ago, ANSAmed reported that a Cairo administrative tribunal had invalidated the ban on the niqab in exam rooms and university areas. (See prior posting.) It is not clear what the relationship is between the two decisions.

A Survey of Law & Religion Casebooks For Law Schools

As the new semester is about to begin, here is a listing of casebooks and teaching materials on law and religion designed for law schools and law students available from major law book publishers (listed alphabetically by author):

• Ariens & Destro, Religious Liberty in a Pluralistic Society, 2d ed., (Carolina Academic Press, 2002).
• Belsky & Bessler-Northcutt, Law and Theology, (Carolina Academic Press, 2005).
• Berg's The State and Religion in a Nutshell, 2d (West Pub., 2004).
• Brownstein and Jacobs's Global Issues in Freedom of Speech and Religion: Cases and Materials (West Pub., 2008).
• Gey, Fonvielle & Hinkle, Religion and the State, 2d ed, (Matthew Bender, 2006).
• Griffin's Law and Religion, Cases and Materials (Foundation Press, 2006) with 2009 Supplement.
• Loewy's Religion and the Constitution: Cases and Materials (West Pub., 1998) with 2002 Supplement.
• McConnell, Harvey & Berg, Religion and the Constitution, 2d ed., (Aspen Publishers, 2006).
• Noonan and Gaffney's Religious Freedom: History, Cases and Other Materials on the Interaction of Religion and Government, 2d ed. (Foundation Press, 2010) (available 4/2010, earlier edition currently available).
• Ravitch's Law and Religion, A Reader: Concepts, Cases and Theory, 2d ed. (West Pub., 2004).
• Volokh's The Religion Clauses and Related Statutes: Problems, Cases and Policy Arguments (Foundation Press, 2005).
  
• UPDATE: Conkle's Constitutional Law - The Religion Clauses, 2d edition (Turning Point Series), (Foundation Press 2009).

Proposed Monument To Secular Government Raises Opposition

Yesterday's Cumberland (MD) Times-News reports on a battle over monuments on public property that has a new twist. Edward W. Taylor Jr., of the Cumberland Historic Cemetery Organization, is objecting to the decision by the Allegany County(MD) Board of Commissioners to allow a monument honoring the U.S. Constitution to be placed on the county court house lawn. It would join a statue of George Washington and a Ten Commandments monument already there. The problem, however, according to opponents is that the new monument will contain an engraving that it was donated by Citizens for a Secular Government. Taylor says that the United States was founded on Judeo-Christian principles, and that the word "secular" should not be included on a monument on public property. He says that backers should place the monument on provate property if they want to put it up. The person behind the new monument to the Constitution is Dr. Jeffrey Davis who, in 2004, led an unsuccessful effort to have the Ten Commandments monument removed from the court house lawn.

British Clergy Want Health & Safety Law Protection

In Britain, clergy are seeking to get legislation to protect their safety in the work place. Today's London Telegraph reports that the Church of England succeeded in 2005 in preventing clergy from being covered by the health and safety laws that protect other employees. Clergy are treated as "office holders" rather than employees. However Unite, the union that represents priests, says that things such as faulty wiring, toppled gravestones and tiles falling off roofs are placing clergy in harms way, as is a lack of security at many vicarages. The government's Department for Business, Innovation and Skills is looking into whether health and safety legislation should be expanded to include clergy.

Hamas Hands Out Islamic Robes To Young Women In Gaza

In Gaza, Hamas in cooperation with the Association of Young Muslim Women is beginning a project to hand out free Islamic robes and veils to young women in secondary schools. Xinhua today reports that the distribution began in two neighborhoods in east Gaza City where 600 robes were distributed. Another 600 will be distributed next week in a central Gaza City neighborhood. A spokesperson for the Association says: "the goal of this project is to disseminate the Islamic dress code and effectively eliminate the wanton behavior." However apparently some of the girls are primarily interested in getting new clothing to replace their worn out clothes that they cannot afford to replace on their own. Hamas' official position is that it is not trying to implement Islamic law in Gaza, but officials in the Hamas government have supported various Islamic virtue campaigns. (See prior

Recent Prisoner Free Exercise Cases

In Peyton v. Felker, 2009 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 120287 (ED CA, Dec. 7, 2009), a California federal district court dismissed, with leave to amend, an inmate's claim that two prison officials retaliated against him after he exercised his First Amendment right to practice his religion.

In Riva v. Secretary of Public Safety, 2009 Mass. App. Unpub. LEXIS 1348 (App. Ct. MA, Dec. 24, 2009), a Massachusetts state appeals court, without reaching the merits, dismissed a claim by a Muslim prisoner who wanted removal of a Nation of Islam chaplain who had been appointed on an interim basis to lead services for Orthodox Muslims. He sought to have a traditional Muslim chaplain appointed, or Muslim inmates lead Friday Jumu'ah services. The court held the wrong parties had been named and that sovereign immunity existed as to a RLUIPA damage claim.

In Howard v. Epps, 2009 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 120182 (SD MS, Dec. 23, 2009), a Mississippi federal district court adopted recommendations of a federal magistrate judge (2009 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 120204, Oct. 30, 2009) and dismissed a complaint by a Rastafarian prisoner that he was not permitted to grow his hair in dreadlocks in accordance with his religious beliefs.

Atheist Group Challenges Ireland's New Blasphemy Law

Ireland's new blasphemy law came into force yesterday. It prohibits intentionally causing outrage among a substantial number of adherents of any religion by publishing or uttering grossly abusive insults to matters held sacred by the religion. Yesterday's London Guardian reported that to challenge the law, a group known as Atheist Ireland published "25 Blasphemous Quotations" on its website. The quotes were from famous figures ranging from Jesus to Mark Twain to Frank Zappa. Atheist Ireland's leader says the group will challenge the blasphemy law through the courts if they are charged under it. Yesterday also was International Blasphemy Day, and Atheist Ireland used the occasion to announce that it was launching a broad-based campaign to both obtain repeal of the blasphemy law and attain a secular Irish Constitution. [Thanks to Scott Mange for a lead on this.]

Danish Cartoonist Who Drew Muhammad Caricature Is Attacked In His Home

In Aaarhus, Denmark yesterday, a 28-year old Somali man broke into the house of cartoonist Kurt Westegaard armed with an axe and a knife, shouting that he wanted to kill the 74-year old Westegaard. Westegaard drew the now-famous caricature of the Prophet Muhammad with a bomb in his turban that was published along with 11 other cartoons in 2005 by the Danish newspaper Jyllands-Posten. The cartoons set off a series of violent demonstrations around the world. (See prior posting.) Today BBC News reports that Westegaard, who was at home with his 5-year old granddaughter, locked himself into a safe room and pressed a special panic button alerting police to the attacker. The suspect, who could not be named under Danish law, tried but failed to break into the safe room and then attacked police with his axe when they arrived. Police shot the suspect outside Westegaard's home. The head of Denmark's intelligence agency says that the attack was "terror related." Apparently the suspect is connected to the radical al-Shabab group in Somalia.

Happy 2010 To Religion Clause Readers!

Dear Religion Clause Readers:

Happy New Year! As we enter 2010, I want to again thank all of you who read Religion Clause-- both long time followers and those who have joined us more recently. With the advent of the Obama administration last January, some readers asked me whether there would continue to be sufficient church-state and religious liberty developments to sustain the blog. I think the past year has shown that this should not have been a concern.

It has been a good year for Religion Clause blog. The site meter shows that the blog has attracted over 672,000 visits since it began in 2005. Approximately 241,700 of these visits were registered in 2009-- a 17% increase over 2008. I continue to seek out additional ways for readers to access Religion Clause. This year I added a feed on Twitter (@ReligionClause). So in addition to the standard method of reading Religion Clause at its URL, you can subscribe to RSS feeds on your favorite RSS reader, subscribe by e-mail, find postings on Lexis through Newstex, log onto Twitter or purchase a subscription to read on your Kindle. Scroll to the bottom of the Religion Clause sidebar to click on various subscription options. One warning however: many of these alternative methods of access do not pick up an item a second time when an Update has been added.

Religion Clause's established format of strict neutrality, broad coverage and links to extensive primary source material has made it a widely-recognized authoritative source for keeping up on church-state and religious liberty developments around the world. I am pleased that my regular readers span the political and religious spectrum. So, while the blog represents a rather substantial investment of time on my part, so long as it continues to serve this unique role, I hope to continue it.

This year, moderating comments has become a more difficult issue. First, I have had a significant increase in robo-generated spam comments. Second, while I attempt to allow a very broad spectrum of views and approaches, I have had to delete some comments that are defamatory, repetitive, hostile, irrelevant or which otherwise impair the blog's usefulness as a neutral resource on legal issues and policy developments. Often I am able to moderate comments several times a day, but sometimes there may be a delay of as much as one or two days in my getting to them.

Finally, I want to thank all of you who send me leads to new developments, or who alert me to needed corrections. These help me assure that coverage is complete and accurate. I read all of your e-mails and appreciate receiving them, even though I cannot always acknowledge them. Normally when I blog on a story sent to me by a reader, I mention the sender. If you do not want me to mention you, I will be happy to honor that request if you let me know when sending me information.

Best wishes for 2010!

Howard M. Friedman

Jordan Seeks Dead Sea Scrolls From Canada Under UN Convention

Invoking the the 1954 Hague Convention for the Protection of Cultural Property in the Event of Armed Conflict, the government of Jordan has asked Canada to seize the portion of the 2000-year old Dead Sea Scrolls that are on display until January 3 from Israel at Toronto's Royal Ontario Museum. Canada, Jordan and Israel have all signed the Convention and its First Protocol. (Signers of Convention, Protocol.) The Convention is aimed at assuring that cultural property is not damaged during armed conflict. Yesterday's Toronto Globe and Mail reports that while the first seven Dead Sea Scrolls were discovered in caves near the Dead Sea in 1947 by Bedouin Arabs and found their way to Israel, the majority of the Scrolls were found in the next seven years in operations supervised by Jordan on land it occupied west of the Jordan River. The thousands of fragments found were taken to the Palestine Archeological Museum in East Jerusalem. When Israel captured East Jerusalem in the 1967 Six Day War, the Israel Antiquities Authority took possession of the Scrolls to conserve and exhibit them at the Israel Museum.

The First Protocol (Art. I, Sec. 2) to the Hague Convention, which has been signed by Canada, Jordan and Israel, is designed to prevent exportation of cultural property during an armed conflict. It requires each signatory:

to take into its custody cultural property imported into its territory either directly or indirectly from any occupied territory. This shall either be effected automatically upon the importation of the property or, failing this, at the request of the authorities of that territory.

Canada's Cultural Property Export and Import Act Sec. 36.1(4), implementing the Convention, provides:

If the government of a State Party submits a request in writing to the Minister for the recovery and return of any cultural property that has been exported from an occupied territory of that State Party and that is in Canada in the possession of or under the control of any person, institution or public authority, the Attorney-General of Canada may institute an action in the Federal Court or in a superior court of a province for the recovery of the property by the State Party.

Israel argues that the temporary loan of the Scrolls for display in Canada does not amount to "exportation" under the Hague Convention, and that the Scrolls, which it says it is merely holding as custodian, are part of the Jewish heritage. Palestinians argue that the Scrolls are also part of their heritage. [Thanks to Vos Iz Neias? for the lead.]

Ex-Indonesian President, Moderate Religious Reformer, Dies

Voice of America reports that former Indonesian president Abdurrahman Wahid (know as Gus Dur) died on Wednesday at the age of 69. In a release issued yesterday, U.S. Commission on International Religious Freedom chair Leonard Leo paid tribute to Dur's interfaith initiatives. He said:

Gus Dur was a renowned religious reformer, a voice of moderation when his country needed it most, and a bridge between Muslims and people of other faiths. His unique voice and perspective will be missed.... His life's mission was to increase religious understanding and reduce religious extremism worldwide. Though the world produces few men of his talents, the mission he lived for should be everyone's goal.

Claims Against Jewish Newspaper Dismissed To Avoid Religious Entanglement

In Abdelhak v. Jewish Press, Inc., (NJ App. Div., Dec. 31, 2009), a New Jersey appellate court dismissed a complaint alleging defamation, invasion of privacy and intentional infliction of emotional distress on the ground that the claims could not be decided without excessively entangling the court in matters of religious doctrine and practice. At issue was a lawsuit by an Orthodox Jewish doctor who was falsely listed by a Jewish newspaper in its "Seruv Listing," a list of men who had been formally held in contempt by a Jewish religious court for refusing to comply with an order to give their wives a Get (Jewish divorce document). (Background.) Plaintiff argued that there cannot be excessive entanglement in violation of the Establishment Clause when the cause of action is secular and the defendants are not religious figures. The court, however, rejected this contention and applied the abstention doctrine, reasoning that:

to evaluate whether plaintiff's reputation suffered any injury, a jury would, of necessity, be required to determine how a Seruv Listing is viewed within the Orthodox Jewish community and whether an Orthodox Jew would be offended by another's refusal to provide a Get. To make that determination, a jury would be obliged to consider the intricacies of Jewish doctrine. Such consideration would require a jury to delve deeply into the importance of giving a Get and the disdain heaped on a man who refuses one.

[Thanks to Bridget Englard for the lead.]