Cert Petition Filed In NYC School Holiday Symbols Case

A petition for certiorari has been filed with the U.S. Supreme Court in Skoros v. Tine, a Second Circuit case in which the Court of Appeals, by a 2-1 vote, upheld a New York City Department of Education policy that allows the menorah to be displayed as a symbol of the Jewish holiday of Chanukkah and the star and crescent to be displayed as a symbol of the Islamic holiday of Ramadan, but permits only secular symbols, and not a creche or nativity scene, to be displayed as a symbol of Christmas. (See prior posting.) The Thomas More Law Center, which yesterday announced its filing of the petition on behalf of a parent and two school children, is apparently asking the Supreme Court to make major changes in its Establishment Clause jurisprudence. The petition asks the Court to abandon the "endorsement test that it increasingly uses in Establishment Clause cases, arguing that the test "is unworkable and incapable of consistent application." It is making this argument, even though the dissent in the 2nd Circuit used the endorsement test as the basis for arguing that the school policy was an unconstitutional endorsement of Judaism and Islam.