Teacher Loses Title VII Challenge To Wearing Of ID Badge

Sidelinger v. Harbor Creek School District, 2006 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 86703 (WD PA, Nov. 29, 2006), is a case brought by a Pennsylvania high school chemistry teacher under Title VII of the 1964 Civil Rights Act claiming that his school failed to accommodate his religious beliefs and that it illegally terminated his employment. Teacher David Sidelinger objected to Harbor Creek High School's requirement that all teachers wear a photo identification badge. He claimed that wearing the badge would require him to commit the sin of pride and the sin of hypocrisy. After a bench trial, the court entered judgment for defendants. It found that Sidelinger had failed to establish that his belief was a sincerely held religious one, that he failed to give sufficient notice of his beliefs to the School District, and that he failed to show that he would not have been fired for reasons independent from his religious beliefs.