7th Circuit: Appeal of Orders In Land Transfer To Catholic School Is Moot and Untimely

In Wirtz v. City of South Bend, (7th Cir., Feb. 7, 2012), the U.S. 7th Circuit Court of Appeals dismissed as untimely and moot an appeal by the city of South Bend, Indiana of two orders by the trial court in litigation over the city's transfer of property to a Catholic high school for an athletic complex.  A district court rejected two plans for the transfer, on Establishment Clause grounds (see prior posting), but ultimately approved the transfer under an arrangement where the Catholic school was the highest bidder. In an appeal from the district court's approval of the transfer, the city seeks to challenge the two previous orders that disapproved earlier plans, arguing that they create precedent that will prevent the city from transferring land to religious institutions in the future. The court said that the city should instead have filed a timely appeal from the first denials.WSBT-TV reports on the decision.