City Officials Denied Attorneys' Fees Despite Plaintiffs' Dismissal of Establishment Clause Challenge

In Arneson v. Grebien, (D RI, May 22, 2013), a Rhode Island federal district court refused to award attorney' fees to Pawtucket, Rhode Island officials who were successful in avoiding liability in a second lawsuit that was brought by city homeowners and taxpayers challenging under the Establishment Clause (as well as on other grounds) the city's policy of allowing Catholic schools to use publicly owned athletic fields without charge. Plaintiffs ultimately voluntarily dismissed their lawsuit, though not for some time after the city prevailed in another lawsuit raising similar, but not identical challenges. (See prior posting.) Nevertheless, the court concluded that the prevailing defendants did not meet the extremely high standard imposed in order to obtain a fee award under 42 USC 1988.