DC Circuit Denies Preliminary Injunction To Non-Liturgical Navy Chaplains Challenging Promotion Procedures

In the long-running challenge to Navy procedures for promoting members of the Chaplain Corps, the D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals yesterday affirmed the district court's denial of a preliminary injunction.  In In re: Navy Chaplaincy, (DC Cir., Dec. 27, 2013), the court ruled against  a group of current and former Navy chaplains and two chaplain-endorsing agencies who claim that the makeup and voting procedures of the Navy's selection boards create a preference for Catholics and liturgical Protestants over various non-liturgical denominations. The court rejected plaintiffs' equal protection claims, agreeing with the district court that plaintiffs' had not shown direct evidence of discriminatory intent in the adoption of the challenged policies that are neutral on their face, nor had they shown sufficiently disparate impact to infer unconstitutional discriminatory intent. The court also rejected plaintiffs' Establishment Clause challenge, finding that a reasonable observer reviewing the data on promotions would not perceive a message of governmental endorsement of liturgical denominations.