Friday, July 16, 2021

8th Circuit: University of Iowa Discriminated Against Christian Student Group

In Intervarsity Christian Fellowship/ USA v. University of Iowa, (8th Cir., July 16, 2021), the U.S. 8th Circuit Court of Appeals held that the University of Iowa violated the 1st Amendment rights of Intervarsity Christian Fellowship when the University applied its Human Rights Policy against ICF in a discriminatory manner. ICF required students seeking leadership positions to affirm a statement of faith based on biblical Christianity-- including the belief that same-sex relationships were against the Bible. The court said in part:

For decades, the University permitted RSOs to base their membership and leadership on religious affirmations or other traits that are protected by the Human Rights Policy.... In fact, the University still permits this; but it didn’t for InterVarsity. The district court found that the defendants likely violated BLinC’s constitutional rights and ordered the University to apply the Human Rights Policy equally to all RSOs. But instead of doing that, the University started a compliance review that prioritized religious organizations. That review led to InterVarsity’s deregistration, along with other religious groups. The University’s fervor dissipated, however, once they finished with religious RSOs. Sororities and fraternities got exemptions from the Human Rights Policy. Other groups were permitted to base membership on sex, race, veteran status, and even some religious beliefs.

Take LoveWorks, for example. It was formed by the student who was denied a leadership role in BLinC. LoveWorks requires its members and leaders to sign a “gay-affirming statement of Christian faith.’” ... Despite that requirement—which violates the Human Rights Policy just as much as InterVarsity’s—the University did nothing. 

We are hard-pressed to find a clearer example of viewpoint discrimination.

Becket issued a press release announcing the decision.