In the Australian state of Victoria, a trial court has held a Catholic Diocese vicariously liable for sexual abuse of a five-year old in 1971 by Bryan Coffee, an assistant parish priest. In DP (a pseudonym) v. Bird, (Sup. Ct. Victoria, Dec. 22, 2021), the court, in a very lengthy opinion, said in part:
278 By reason of —(a) the close nature of the relationship between the Bishop, the Diocese and the Catholic community in Port Fairy; (b) the Diocese’s general control over Coffey’s role and duties within St Patrick’s parish; (c) Coffey’s pastoral role in the Port Fairy Catholic community; and (d) the relationship between DP, his family, Coffey and the Diocese, which was one of intimacy and imported trust in the authority of Christ’s representative, personified by Coffey — the Diocese is vicariously liable for his conduct....
280 I am also satisfied that Coffey’s role as a priest under the direction of the Diocese placed him in a position of power and intimacy vis-à-vis DP that enabled him to take advantage of DP when alone — just as he did with other boys. This position significantly increased the risk of harm to DP....
However the court refused to hold the Diocese liable on a direct negligence claim, concluding that Coffee's actions were not a foreseeable risk. Law and Religion Australia and ABC Australia News reports at length on the decision, saying that this is the first time that an Australian court has found a diocese vicariously liable for actions of a priest. [Thanks to Law & Religion UK for the lead.]
