Freedom From Religion Foundation, Inc. v. Abbott, (WD TX, June 5, 2024), is an opinion and order requiring the state of Texas to pay Freedom From Religion Foundation an award of attorneys' fees and costs totaling $346,500 that had been entered against the state in January 2024. The award grew out of long-running litigation challenging the state's action in 2015 removing from the state Capitol building FFRF's Bill of Rights Nativity display. (See prior posting.) Texas contended that under state law, the judgment against it could only be paid through an appropriation from the state legislature which would come on September 1, 2025, at the earliest. The court said in part:
The Court finds that it is empowered to compel execution of the judgment. Given that Defendants maintain that they lack the ability to disburse these funds prior to the end of next year, it appears to the Court that “an order directing the responsible state official to satisfy the judgment out of state funds is the only reasonable way to ensure compliance with a valid federal judgment.”... While the Court acknowledges that execution of the judgment is a drastic step, the Court believes that this step is warranted to ensure that FFRF timely recovers for Defendants’ federal civil rights violation. Texas “may not successfully hide behind state procedural shields to avoid the consequences of a valid district court judgment effectuating an appropriate § 1988 award.”
The court ordered this payment to be made by August 5, 2024. It also allowed FFRF to recover for attorneys' fees and costs incurred in enforcing payment of the prior award.
