Minnesota provides for a state income tax deduction, and in some cases a refundable tax credit, for the cost of textbooks, educational materials and tuition, up to specified dollar amounts. However, the law excludes expenses for teaching of religion or religious doctrines. Suit was filed this week in the Minnesota Tax Court challenging these exclusions as violating the Free Exercise clause, the Freedom of Conscience clause of the Minnesota Constitution and the right to control the education and upbringing of one's children. The complaint (full text) in Colestock v. Marquart, (MN Tax Ct., filed 11/16/2026), alleges in part:
86. ... Minnesota has no compelling interest in excluding religious instruction from an otherwise generally available educational-expense benefit, and the exclusion is not narrowly tailored to any such interest. Teaching a child to add fractions does not lose its academic value merely because the lesson begins in prayer or is taught by someone who is deeply religious and incorporates religious teaching into all academic subjects.
94. The Subtraction and Credit are public benefits. Defendant "cannot 'condition' [their] 'availability' on parents willingness to accept a burden on their religious exercise."...
95. Because the Religious Exclusion substantially interferes with Pastor Colestock and Mr. Osburn's religious upbringing of their children, it receives strict scrutiny regardless of whether it is neutral and generally applicable....
110. Here, the Religious Exclusion "singles out the religious for disfavored treatment" and is thus not neutral....
111.... [T]he government fails general applicability when it can hand out "entirely discretionary exceptions" from the challenged rule or conduct....
113. Because Defendant—in his discretion—can allow some expenses to be claimed as not religious while denying other expenses because they are too religious in his view, the law is not generally applicable....
ADF issued a press release announcing the filing of the lawsuit.