Monday, November 16, 2026

Trademark Claims by Anglican Chaplaincy Organization Dismissed Under Ecclesiastical Abstention Doctrine

In a case decided two months ago, Jurisdiction of the Armed Forces and Chaplaincy v. Anglican Church in North America, (D SC, Sept. 28, 2026), a South Carolina federal district court invoked the ecclesiastical abstention doctrine in a complex organizational dispute.  Jurisdiction of the Armed Forces and Chaplaincy is an organization that endorses Anglican chaplains who serve in the armed forces or in other chaplaincy positions. Last year it notified the Archbishop that it was withdrawing from the Anglican Church of North America. In a Pastoral Letter dated Sept. 25, 2025 (full text), the Archbishop contended that the JAFC cannot withdraw because it is not a diocese but instead is a canonical ministry. On October 6, 2025, JAFC filed suit contending that the Anglican Church in North America is violating the Lanham Act, the Defend Trade Secrets Act and the South Carolina Unfair Trade Practices Act by using the phrases Anglican Chaplains and a logo that JAFC  had registered as a trademark. The court said in part:

Plaintiff specifically introduces its complaint by emphasizing that the claims do not involve “a dispute between the parties concerning church discipline, church governance, or any other ecclesiastical matter.” ...  Indeed, Plaintiff carefully pleads its claims as those of a corporate plaintiff who has suffered as a result of the alleged unlawful actions of a corporate defendant through its agents and CEO....

Plaintiff asserts that on September 21, 2025, Defendant “interfered with the governance of Plaintiff by purporting to ‘inhibit’ the activities of Plaintiff’s CEO and ecclesiastical head, Bishop Jones.” ... According to Plaintiff, Defendant did so to “usurp Plaintiff’s chaplain-endorsement authority and take over control of Plaintiff’s global network of parishes, missions, and chapels.”...

According to Plaintiff, Defendant’s actions were motivated by malice on the part of Defendant’s leadership towards Bishop Jones....

Stated succinctly, the Court finds that Plaintiff’s claims clearly involve matters not only of Bishop Jones’ church discipline, but also fundamental questions of internal church organization and polity.  Indeed, to adjudicate any of Plaintiff’s claims, the Court would be forced to wade into these ecclesiastical disputes and delve into, for example, the extent to which both Bishop Jones and Plaintiff are subject to the ecclesiastical control of Defendant,which the Court believes would run afoul of the First Amendment....

Anglican Ink reported on the decision.