Church Fails In RLUIPA Challenge To Village's Zoning Ordinance

In Truth Foundation Ministries, NFP v. Village of Romeoville, (ND IL, Feb. 26, 2016), an Illinois federal district court denied a preliminary injunction to a small congregation serving mainly African immigrants that found itself in violation of the village's zoning code after it had spent over $50,000 expanding a building it was leasing for use as a church.  The court concluded that the church had failed to show a substantial likelihood of success in its claim that the town's zoning requirements violate RLUIPA's complete exclusion, unreasonable exclusion and equal terms provisions.

Clergy-Penitent Privilege Does Not Shield Disclosure of Writer of Defamatory Letter

In Jaime Doe v. Catholic Diocese of Rockford, (IL App., Sept. 4, 2015), plaintiff sued seeking the identity of the writer of an allegedly defamatory letter about her son.  The letter, sent to the pastor of the parish, alleged that plaintiff's son engaged in the sexual touching of another minor child.  The appeals court affirmed the trial court's order that the writer of the letter be disclosed.  In doing so, the court concluded that the letter is not covered by the Clergy-Penitent Privilege, saying in part:

The writer was a volunteer for a religious-education program conducted by the parish and had the responsibility of monitoring the children in the program. In our view, at least on the present record, the statements in issue are simply not of the character of a confession or admission for which the writer was seeking spiritual guidance. Rather, they are outlining a potential source of risk for the parish and the children if J. Doe were to repeat such conduct while participating in the educational program offered by the parish. This is fundamentally not a matter of conscience for the writer; rather it is a matter of risk management for the writer as an agent of the parish and a guardian of children. Accordingly, we hold that the clergy-penitent privilege is simply inapplicable.

Illinois Milk Law Change Was Pushed By Orthodox Jewish Group

Earlier this month (Aug. 6), Illinois Governor Bruce Rauner signed into law (effective next January) Illinois S.B. 1228 (full text) amending the state's Grade A Pasteurized Milk and Milk Products Act.  The new law requires milk in the state to be labeled in accordance with the federal Model Grade "A" Pasteurized Milk Ordinance.  The major change this makes stems from the provision in the federal model ordinance stating: "The common name of the hooved mammal producing the milk shall precede the name of the milk or milk product when the product is or is made from other than cattle's milk."  It turns out, according to a JTA report this week, that the primary proponent of this change was the Chicago Rabbinical Council, an Orthodox rabbinical and kosher certification organization.  Under Illinois' prior law, products sold as milk could have contained non-kosher milk from pigs or camels without the consumer being aware of that fact.

Illinois Becomes 4th State To Ban Gay Conversion Therapy For Minors

As reported by the Huffington Post, yesterday Illinois became the fourth state to ban gay conversion therapy for minors.  Governor Bruce Rauner signed HB 217 (full text), the Youth Mental Health Protection Act which prohibits any mental health provider from engaging in sexual orientation change efforts with a person under the age of 18. The new law also broadly prohibits misleading advertising of conversion therapy:

No person or entity may, in the conduct of any trade or commerce, use or employ any deception, fraud, false pretense, false promise, misrepresentation, or the concealment, suppression, or omission of any material fact in advertising or otherwise offering conversion therapy services in a manner that represents homosexuality as a mental disease, disorder, or illness, with intent that others rely upon the concealment, suppression, or omission of such material fact. A violation of this Section constitutes an unlawful practice under the Consumer Fraud and Deceptive Business Practices Act.

The new law, which becomes effective Jan. 1, 2016, includes extensive legislative findings supporting the therapy ban.

Orthodox Jewish School Loses RLUIPA Zoning Challenge

In Joan Dachs Bais Yaakov Elementary School v. City of Evanston, (IL App., March 6, 2015), an Illinois appellate court rejected a RLUIPA challenge brought by an Orthodox Jewish elementary school after Evanston City Council refused zoning modifications that would allow the construction of a school on property in an industrial zone that plaintiff had purchased.  Rejecting the school's reliance on RLUIPA's equal terms provision, the court said:

Unlike its nonreligious comparators, the removal of the ... property from the property tax rolls would deprive Evanston of hundreds of thousands of dollars annually in property tax revenue at a time when approximately 40% of its land is already off the tax rolls. The generation of tax revenues is a legitimate concern of land-use regulation.... and, thus, renders JDBY, which is not subject to property taxes, dissimilar to its nonreligious comparators who are subject to such taxes.

The court also upheld a trial court finding that RLUIPA's nondiscrimination provisions had not been violated.  RLUIPA Defense blog has more on the decision.

Illinois Bible Colleges Sue Over Rules On Granting Degrees

AP reports that a lawsuit was filed in Illinois federal district court yesterday by the Illinois Bible Colleges Association challenging Illinois Board of Higher Education rules that prevent Bible colleges from awarding full-fledged "degrees" to their graduates.  They can only award "diplomas" or "certificates" since the religious schools do not offer full collegiate curriculums. The schools say that the state is violating their free exercise and speech rights, as well as ignoring the Establishment Clause, by imposing the regulations on them.

Ecclesiastical Abstention Doctrine Leads To Dismissal of Suit Over Church's Board

In Ivanov v. Notzkov, 2014 Ill. App. Unpub. LEXIS 577 (IL App., March 25, 2014), an Illinois Court of Appeals affirmed the trial court's reliance on the ecclesiastical abstention doctrine in dismissing a lawsuit  between two factions of St. John of Rila Bulgarian Eastern Orthodox Church.  The court refused to order a membership meeting to elect a new board, relying on the trial court's findings that St. John's is governed by the Bulgarian Eastern Orthodox Church which gave the parish priest and archbishop authority to determine who are members in good standing that may vote in an election for the church's board. The trial court had concluded that passing on plaintiffs' claim that the clergy did not have the power to appoint members to the board of trustees would require it to decide matters of religious doctrine and polity.

City Council Members Have Legislative Immunity In Suit Over Zoning Vote

In American Islamic Center v. City of Des Plaines, (ND IL, March 24, 2014), an Illinois federal district court held that city council members are entitled to absolute legislative immunity from a suit against them for their vote against a zoning map amendment that would have permitted an Islamic center to build in an area currently zoned for manufacturing.  The Islamic Center's free exercise and equal protection claims can proceed only against the city itself. The court held that it need not decide at this juncture whether the Illinois Tort Immunity Act applies to claims under the Illinois Religious Freedom Restoration Act.  It permitted plaintiff to proceed with its claim that the zoning decision was arbitrary and capricious in violation of the state constitution.

Court Rules That Illinois Same Sex Couples Can Wed Immediately In Cook County

In Lee v. Orr, (ND IL, Feb. 21, 2014), an Illinois federal district court, in a 4-page opinion, held that Illinois statutes barring same-sex marriages violate the 14th Amendment's equal protection clause by discriminating on the basis of sexual orientation.  Illinois has already enacted a law allowing same-sex marriages, but that law does not take effect until June 1. (See prior posting.) In this decision, however, the court ruled that same-sex couples need not wait for June:

There is no reason to delay further when no opposition has been presented to this Court and committed gay and lesbian couples have already suffered from the denial of their fundamental right to marry.

However because the suit was filed only against the Cook County Clerk, the court's decision applies only to marriage licenses issued by Cook County. The Chicago Tribune reports that same-sex couples began lining up for marriage licenses within an hour after the ruling was issued.

Two Decisions Follow On Illinois Legalization Of Same-Sex Marriage

As previously reported, last month Illinois Governor Pat Quinn signed legislation legalizing same-sex marriage in the state, effective June 1, 2014. There have now been two follow-up judicial developments. As reported by Illinois Review, yesterday, with the backing of all parties, an Illinois state trial court judge dismissed as moot the complaint in Darby v. Orr, a suit filed last year by the ACLU and Lambda Legal challenging the constitutionality of Illinois' previous prohibition of same-sex marriage.

Meanwhile, in Lee v. Orr, (ND IL, Dec. 10, 2013), an Illinois federal district court issued an opinion in a class action lawsuit granting a temporary injunction allowing  individuals in same-sex relationships who need to marry before to June 1, 2014 due to a life-threatening illness of one or both parties the right to do so. The court said:

The putative subclass of medically critical plaintiffs here are likely to succeed on the merits of their claim that the provisions of the current Illinois law that deny them the right to marry based solely on their sexual orientation, as applied, violates their constitutional right to equal protection.

The court's decision was contingent on the parties agreeing on a satisfactory implementation method.  They have done so.  As announced by the ACLU,  the court finalized its order yesterday adopting a procedure that allows same-sex couples to marry before June 1 if they provide a doctor’s certification stating that one of them has a life-threatening illness. Still pending in the case is the broader attempt by plaintiffs to speed up the same-sex marriage implementation date for everyone.

Illinois Governor Signs Marriage Equality Law; Catholic Bishop Responds With Exorcism Prayers

The Chicago Tribune reports that yesterday Illinois Governor Pat Quinn signed into law the Religious Freedom and Marriage Fairness Act, legalizing same-sex marriage in the state. (See prior related posting.) The law takes effect June 1, though some are pressing for additional legislation to speed up the effective date.  Meanwhile, in Springfield, Illinois, Catholic Bishop Thomas Paprocki held a a service, largely in Latin, to offer Prayers of Supplication and Exorcism in Reparation for the Sin of Same-Sex Marriage.  In his homily (full text), he said in part:

Our prayers at this time are prompted by the fact that the Governor of Illinois today is signing into Illinois law the redefinition of civil marriage, introducing not only an unprecedented novelty into our state law, but also institutionalizing an objectively sinful reality....

Our prayer service today and my words are not meant to demonize anyone, but are intended to call attention to the diabolical influences of the devil that have penetrated our culture, both in the state and in the Church....

Since the legal redefinition of marriage is contrary to God's plan, those who contract civil same-sex marriage are culpable of serious sin. Politicians responsible for enacting civil same-sex marriage legislation are morally complicit as co-operators in facilitating this grave sin.....

We must also affirm the teaching of the Catholic Church that homosexual persons "must be accepted with respect, compassion, and sensitivity....." The Church loves homosexual persons and looks upon them with compassion, offering assistance through support groups such as the Courage Apostolate to live in accord with the virtue of chastity.