Thursday, September 22, 2005

RI Supreme Court Rejects Opening Birth Records Based On Mormon Beliefs

On Sept. 19, in In re Philip S., the Rhode Island Supreme Court ruled against an adoptee, now an adult, who claimed that his Mormon religious beliefs should permit him to discover the identity of his birth mother. He claimed that he had a religious duty to trace his ancestry. Additional details of the case, in which the court placed a high value on confidentiality of adoption proceedings, are reported in today's Providence Journal. The Court avoided ultimately deciding a difficult constitutional issue by holding that the petitioner presented the Family Court with no meaningful evidence to support his claim of good cause to open his records other than his own subjective assertions about what he considered to be the requirements of his religion. In a footnote, however, the Court said: "While we make no definitive holding at this time, it is our tentative view that, unless a petitioner’s religious beliefs can be “translated” into a more secular context (such as being a constituent element of a particular petitioner’s psychological need), we do not see how deferring to such a belief would be anything other than a preferential treatment by government based upon religion."