Sunday, October 23, 2005

Dispute Over Display of Crucifix In Italian Courtroom

In northern Italy, in the town of Carmerino, a judge is refusing to hold court until there are some concession on church-state issues. The Australian reports today that Judge Luigi Tosti objects to the crucifix hanging in his courtroom. While Tosti was baptized as a Catholic, he objects to favoring one religion. He either wants the crucifix taken down, or a Jewish candelabrum displayed alongside it. Judge Tosti says: "In public offices, the cross is the only theological symbol on display. That's like saying white people can come in and the blacks stay outside. It's a form of religious discrimination."

The same kind of issue has arisen elsewhere in Italy. In 2003, Muslim activist Adel Smith tried to get a crucifix removed from his son's classroom. An appeals judge ruled that the cross could stay, as a symbol of Italy's cultural heritage and values. Subsequently Smith engaged in self-help. When nurses treating his mother in a public hospital refused to take down the crucifix above her bed, he tossed it out the window.

UPDATE: On Nov. 18, Judge Tosti was convicted of failing to carry out his official duties and was sentenced to seven months in jail, according to the Associated Press. An appeal is planned.