Wednesday, May 30, 2007

Georgia Court Says Harry Potter Books Can Stay In School Library

In suburban Atlanta yesterday, according to the Associated Press, a Superior Court judge upheld the refusal by the Gwinnett County school board to remove Harry Potter books from school libraries. Laura Mallory, a parent of two school children, had requested removal of the books, saying they promote witchcraft. Part of Mallory's argument in yesterday's hearing-- at which she represented herself-- was that since witchcraft is a religion, keeping the books in the library violates the Establishment Clause. That argument, however, is hardly consistent with another statement by Mallory: "I have a dream that God will be welcomed back in our schools again." The local school district and the state board of education had both previously rejected Mallory's request, saying that the books spark student creativity and imagination. The court held that the evidence presented supported the school's decision to leave the books in the library. (See prior related posting.) [Thanks to Jack Shattuck for the lead.]