Wednesday, July 09, 2008

Defense Department Moves To Dismiss Suit Claiming Religious Discrimination

God and Country blog reports that yesterday the Defense Department filed a motion to dismiss and a memorandum in support of the motion (full text) in Hall v. Welborn. In March, Jeremy Hall and the Military Religious Freedom Foundation filed suit in federal district court in Kansas claiming that a meeting of atheists and freethinkers organized by Hall in Iraq was interrupted by an Army major, and that Hall was not recommended for promotion because his platoon sergeant thought he would be "unable to put aside his personal convictions and pray with his troops" and would have trouble bonding with them. (See prior posting.) In support of its motion to dismiss, the Defense Department argued that the court need not reach the merits. It contends that because Hall did not show that the major's action was likely to recur, he lacked standing to obtain an injunction. It claimed that Hall failed to use existing internal procedures to complain about his treatment and that he did not show injury from the alleged pattern and practice in support of religion. It also argued that judicial review would interfere with military operations and personnel matters committed to military expertise.