Friday, October 30, 2009

Halloween Creates Church-State Puzzle For Some Schools

Tomorrow is Halloween, a holiday which has varied religious connections. It has roots in the Celtic festival of Samhain. In the 7th and 8th centuries, the Catholic Church tried to co-opt the day as the eve of All Saints Day. Some Protestant groups have used it as a celebration of the Reformation. More recently some Christians have rejected Halloween because they see it as celebrating the occult or promoting Satanism, or stemming from Pagan origins. (Background from Wikipedia.) No wonder all of this is confusing to school officials concerned about maintaining the proper line between church and state. Guampdn reported yesterday that at C.L. Taitano Elementary School in the Guam town of Sinajana, Halloween celebrations were replaced by a costume parade designed to promote literacy. Students could dress up as a character from any book they had read.

Last month, Guam Department of Education legal counsel Fred Nishihira sent out a routine annual notice to principals telling them that they must remain neutral in their treatment of religion. The memo allowed him to provide the required annual certification to the U.S. Department of Education that Guam schools are complying with the separation of church and state. Nishihira's memo created uncertainty for C.L. Taitano principal Corina Paulino as to whether a Halloween celebration would be permissible. So, out of an abundance of caution, she scheduled the book character costume parade instead. Nishihira said that when he sent out the religious neutrality memo, the question of Halloween had not occurred to him.