Wednesday, September 12, 2012

Israeli Court Rejects Reception Hall Owners' Religious Objections To Same-Sex Marriage

According to Haaretz today, the Jerusalem Magistrate's Court has for the first time under Israeli law held that owners of a reception hall may not refuse on religious grounds to host a same-sex wedding reception. The court awarded damages of 60,000 NIS ($15,196 US) and imposed 20,000 NIS in legal fees and court costs on the owners of the reception hall who are members of a sect of Messianic Jews. A lesbian couple, Tal Ya'akovovich and Yael Biran, booked the hall for a reception, but the owners canceled the reservation when they realized the reception was for a same-sex couple. The owners say that based on verses from the Old and New Testaments, they believe that homosexuality is an "abomination." The court refused to accept the owners' claim that their business has a religious character.  The court said:
Every person who opens a public business in Israel should know that they must serve the whole public equally, without discrimination, according to laws, which cover sexual orientation as well. As soon as the defendants opened their doors to all, they cannot close them for those who they believe do not meet the requirements found in the Bible or New Testament, thereby damaging their dignity and sensitivities.
The court also said:
Rejection, verbal abuse, and humiliation of another based on their sex or sexual orientation constitutes sexual harassment. Sexual harassment does not only include sexual exploitation, but also, and perhaps principally, ridiculing another person for their sex or sexual orientation… and in this case, the plaintiffs were ridiculed because of their sexual orientation