Saturday, June 29, 2013

Procedural Wrangling Tries To Delay Same-Sex Marriages In California

In its widely reported decision in Hollingsworth v. Perry last Wednesday, the U.S. Supreme Court held that petitioners lacked standing to challenge California's anti-gay marriage Proposition 8. SCOTUS remanded the case and ordered the 9th Circuit to dismiss the appeal from the district court. However it will be at least 25 days from the decision date until the Supreme Court formally certifies a copy of its judgment to the 9th Circuit.  Nevertheless, acting quickly, yesterday the 9th Circuit issued an Order (full text) dissolving the stay it had previously entered. That stay was the last impediment to same-sex marriage in California. Today, as same-sex marriages were being performed in the state, the proponents of Proposition 8 filed a motion (full text) with the U.S. Supreme Court asking it to vacate yesterday's 9th Circuit order on the ground that the 9th Circuit has no jurisdiction to act until the Supreme Court formally issues a certified copy of its judgment to it. Proponents argued that the premature termination of the stay deprives them of a meaningful opportunity to petition the Supreme Court for a rehearing. The Los Angeles Times and SCOTUS Blog report on this latest procedural wrangling.

UPDATE: AP reports that on June 30, Justice Anthony Kennedy denied the motion to vacate the 9th Circuit's order. Kennedy is the Justice assigned to receive motions regarding 9th Circuit cases.