Ecclesiastical Abstention Does Not Require Dismissal of Negligent Supervision Claim

In Bourque v. Roman Catholic Diocese of Charlotte, NC, (NC App., Nov. 20, 2018), a North Carolina appellate court held that the ecclesiastical abstention doctrine does not require dismissal of a suit alleging negligent supervision and negligent infliction of emotional distress. However it does require dismissal of a negligent hiring claim. The suit alleges that a male church youth leader raped a 14-year old female who sought counsel from him about being bullied. Four years later, he repeatedly raped her again. The court said in part:

Plaintiffs’ claim is not barred by the First Amendment because determining whether Bishop Jugis and the Diocese knew or had reason to know of Defendant’s proclivities for sexual wrongdoing requires only the application of neutral principles of tort law, and “the application of a secular standard to secular conduct that is tortious is not prohibited by the Constitution.”