Court Upholds Maryland Hate Crime Statute

In Lipp v. State of Maryland, (MD Ct. Special Appeals, April 30, 2020), a Maryland state appellate court upheld the constitutionality of a Maryland statute which outlawed the destruction of property where there is evidence of animosity toward a group because of race, religious belief, sexual orientation, gender, disability, national origin or homelessness. Defendant had been convicted of spraying anti-Semitic, anti-Black and anti-gay graffiti on a school building.  Rejecting defendant's constitutional arguments, the court said in part:

Appellant may have had a First Amendment right to spray paint on his own property the offensive words and symbols used here. Once he combined that action with a criminal act, however, in this case defacing property of another, his criminal activity was not protected by the First Amendment.