In K.K. & K.K. v. Comer, (ED TN, Nov. 5, 2021), a Tennessee federal district court dismissed a suit brought by the married lesbian mothers of a middle school student challenging a before-school basketball program which allowed students to participate only if they also participated in the Teens For Christ Club. The court dismissed the claim against the Knox County Board of Education, saying in part:
Plaintiff’s allegations only suggest that a policymaker was aware of the existence of the Teens for Christ Club, but Plaintiff’s allegations do not go so far as to make it plausible that a final policymaker was put on notice of ongoing unconstitutional conduct like the alleged condition precedent.
The court also found that plaintiffs had failed to allege sufficient facts to support their claim that the school board failed to adequately train employees.
In addition, the court went on to dismiss the Establishment Clause claim brought against the physical education teacher involved on qualified immunity grounds, saying in part:
Defendant Comer argues that the Court must assume that he was reading from the Bible and proselytizing to voluntary participants of the Teens for Christ Club and simply allowed those participants to shoot basketballs in the gymnasium before school. Lastly, Defendant Comer asserts that while he was allegedly reading from the Bible to the voluntary participants, he was lawfully exercising his own First Amendment rights....
Plaintiff cites to no caselaw clearly establishing that it is patently unconstitutional for a teacher like Defendant Comer to allow a religious school club to use the school gymnasium to shoot basketballs outside of regular school hours.
