Tuesday, November 09, 2021

Labor Department Proposes Rescinding Trump Era's Broad Religious Employer Exemption Rule

The Department of Labor yesterday released a proposal (full text) to rescind a Trump Administration rule (see prior posting) that defined expansively the religious exemption in the agency's rules imposing anti-discrimination requirements on government contractors and subcontractors. Yesterday's Release says in part:

OFCCP believes that the 2020 rule creates a lack of clarity regarding the scope and application of the exemption because ... it misstates the law in key respects. In addition, as a threshold matter, OFCCP has reevaluated the need for the rule. For the 17 years prior to 2020, OFCCP implemented the Executive Order 11246 religious exemption without seeking to codify its scope and application in specific regulatory language....

[T]he 2020 rule creates its own religious employer test, independent of Title VII case law interpreting the identical term. The test adopted in the 2020 rule permits a contractor whose purpose and/or character is not primarily religious to qualify for the Executive Order 11246 religious exemption....

In addition, the 2020 rule retreats from the general principle that qualifying religious employers are prohibited from taking employment actions that amount to discrimination on the basis of protected characteristics other than religion, even if the decisions are made for sincerely held religious reasons....

FCW reports on the proposed rule rescission.