In Oliver v. Arnold, (5th Cir., Dec. 15, 2021), the U.S. 5th Circuit Court of Appeals by a vote of 7-10 denied an en banc rehearing in a suit against a Texas high school teacher by a former student who refused on religious grounds to transcribe the Pledge of Allegiance as part of an assignment. The student alleges that she was retaliated against by the teacher. The district court refused to grant summary judgment on the teacher's qualified immunity defense and a 3-judge appellate panel, in a 2-1 decision, agreed. (See prior posting). Judge Ho filed a 19-page opinion concurring the denial of an en banc rehearing of the panel's decision. Three dissenting opinions spanning 15 pages were also filed. Among the issues raised by these are whether the teacher's motive in giving the assignment is relevant and whether the Supreme Court's flag salute cases apply to written school assignments in addition to ceremonies.
